Operators commonly have docker logs aggregated using various tools and
don't need nomad to manage their docker logs. Worse, Nomad uses a
somewhat heavy docker api call to collect them and it seems to cause
problems when a client runs hundreds of log collections.
Here we add a knob to disable log aggregation completely for nomad.
When log collection is disabled, we avoid running logmon and
docker_logger for the docker tasks in this implementation.
The downside here is once disabled, `nomad logs ...` commands and API
no longer return logs and operators must corrolate alloc-ids with their
aggregated log info.
This is meant as a stop gap measure. Ideally, we'd follow up with at
least two changes:
First, we should optimize behavior when we can such that operators don't
need to disable docker log collection. Potentially by reverting to
using pre-0.9 syslog aggregation in linux environments, though with
different trade-offs.
Second, when/if logs are disabled, nomad logs endpoints should lookup
docker logs api on demand. This ensures that the cost of log collection
is paid sparingly.
Currently, when logmon fails to reattach, we will retry reattachment to
the same pid until the task restart specification is exhausted.
Because we cannot clear hook state during error conditions, it is not
possible for us to signal to a future restart that it _shouldn't_
attempt to reattach to the plugin.
Here we revert to explicitly detecting reattachment seperately from a
launch of a new logmon, so we can recover from scenarios where a logmon
plugin has failed.
This is a net improvement over the current hard failure situation, as it
means in the most common case (the pid has gone away), we can recover.
Other reattachment failure modes where the plugin may still be running
could potentially cause a duplicate process, or a subsequent failure to launch
a new plugin.
If there was a duplicate process, it could potentially cause duplicate
logging. This is better than a production workload outage.
If there was a subsequent failure to launch a new plugin, it would fail
in the same (retry until restarts are exhausted) as the current failure
mode.
This commit is a significant change. TR.Run is now always executed, even
for terminal allocations. This was changed to allow TR.Run to cleanup
(run stop hooks) if a handle was recovered.
This is intended to handle the case of Nomad receiving a
DesiredStatus=Stop allocation update, persisting it, but crashing before
stopping AR/TR.
The commit also renames task runner hook data as it was very easy to
accidently set state on Requests instead of Responses using the old
field names.
This code chooses to be conservative as opposed to optimal: when failing
to reattach to logmon simply return a recoverable error instead of
immediately trying to restart logmon.
The recoverable error will cause the task's restart policy to be
applied and a new logmon will be launched upon restart.
Trying to do the optimal approach of simply starting a new logmon
requires error string comparison and should be tested against a task
actively logging to assert the behavior (are writes blocked? dropped?).
There were multiple bugs here:
1. Reattach unmarshalling always returned an error because you can't
unmarshal into a nil pointer.
2. The hook data wasn't being saved because it was put on the request
struct, not the response struct.
3. The plugin configuration should only have reattach *or* a command
set. Not both.
4. Setting Done=true meant the hook was never re-run on agent restart so
reattaching was never attempted.
