Previously, it was required that you `go get github.com/hashicorp/nomad` to be
able to build protos, as the protoc invocation added an include directive that
pointed to `$GOPATH/src`, which is how dependent protos were discovered. As
Nomad now uses Go modules, it won't necessarily be cloned to `$GOPATH`.
(Additionally, if you _had_ go-gotten Nomad at some point, protoc compilation
would have possibly used the _wrong_ protos, as those wouldn't necessarily be
the most up-to-date ones.)
This change modifies the proto files and the `protoc` invocation to handle
discovering dependent protos via protoc plugin modifier statements that are
specific to the protoc plugin being used.
In this change, `make proto` was run to recompile the protos, which results in
changes only to the gzipped `FileDescriptorProto`.
The CSI specification for `ValidateVolumeCapability` says that we shall
"reconcile successful capability-validation responses by comparing the
validated capabilities with those that it had originally requested" but leaves
the details of that reconcilation unspecified. This API is not implemented in
Kubernetes, so controller plugins don't have a real-world implementation to
verify their behavior against.
We have found that CSI plugins in the wild may return "successful" but
incomplete `VolumeCapability` responses, so we can't require that all
capabilities we expect have been validated, only that the ones that have been
validated match. This appears to violate the CSI specification but until
that's been resolved in upstream we have to loosen our validation
requirements. The tradeoff is that we're more likely to have runtime errors
during `NodeStageVolume` instead of at the time of volume registration.
In systemd-resolved hosts with no DNS customizations, the docker driver
DNS setting should be compared to /run/systemd/resolve/resolv.conf while
exec/java drivers should be compared to /etc/resolv.conf.
When system-resolved is enabled, /etc/resolv.conf is a stub that points
to 127.0.0.53. Docker avoids this stub because this address isn't
accessible from the container. The exec/java drivers that don't create
network isolations use the stub though in the default configuration.
* docker: support group allocated ports
* docker: add new ports driver config to specify which group ports are mapped
* docker: update port mapping docs
When the client-side actions of a CSI client RPC succeed but we get
disconnected during the RPC or we fail to checkpoint the claim state, we want
to be able to retry the client RPC without getting blocked by the client-side
state (ex. mount points) already having been cleaned up in previous calls.
In #7957 we added support for passing a volume context to the controller RPCs.
This is an opaque map that's created by `CreateVolume` or, in Nomad's case,
in the volume registration spec.
However, we missed passing this field to the `NodeStage` and `NodePublish` RPC,
which prevents certain plugins (such as MooseFS) from making node RPCs.
This fixes few cases where driver eventor goroutines are leaked during
normal operations, but especially so in tests.
This change makes few modifications:
First, it switches drivers to use `Context`s to manage shutdown events.
Previously, it relied on callers invoking `.Shutdown()` function that is
specific to internal drivers only and require casting. Using `Contexts`
provide a consistent idiomatic way to manage lifecycle for both internal
and external drivers.
Also, I discovered few places where we don't clean up a temporary driver
instance in the plugin catalog code, where we dispense a driver to
inspect and validate the schema config without properly cleaning it up.
When an allocation runs for a task driver that can't support volume mounts,
the mounting will fail in a way that can be hard to understand. With host
volumes this usually means failing silently, whereas with CSI the operator
gets inscrutable internals exposed in the `nomad alloc status`.
This changeset adds a MountConfig field to the task driver Capabilities
response. We validate this when the `csi_hook` or `volume_hook` fires and
return a user-friendly error.
Note that we don't currently have a way to get driver capabilities up to the
server, except through attributes. Validating this when the user initially
submits the jobspec would be even better than what we're doing here (and could
be useful for all our other capabilities), but that's out of scope for this
changeset.
Also note that the MountConfig enum starts with "supports all" in order to
support community plugins in a backwards compatible way, rather than cutting
them off from volume mounting unexpectedly.
Some CSI plugins don't return much for errors over the gRPC socket
above and beyond the bare minimum error codes. This changeset improves
the operator experience by unpacking the error codes when available
and wrapping the error with some user-friendly direction.
Improving these errors also revealed a bad comparison with
`require.Error` when `require.EqualError` should be used in the test
code for plugin errors. This defect in turn was hiding a bug in volume
validation where we're being overly permissive in allowing mount
flags, which is now fixed.
The plugin supervisor lazily connects to plugins, but this means we
only get "Unavailable" back from the gRPC call in cases where the
plugin can never be reached (for example, if the Nomad client has the
wrong permissions for the socket).
This changeset improves the operator experience by switching to a
blocking `DialWithContext`. It eagerly connects so that we can
validate the connection is real and get a "failed to open" error in
case where Nomad can't establish the initial connection.
The MVP for CSI in the 0.11.0 release of Nomad did not include support
for opaque volume parameters or volume context. This changeset adds
support for both.
This also moves args for ControllerValidateCapabilities into a struct.
The CSI plugin `ControllerValidateCapabilities` struct that we turn
into a CSI RPC is accumulating arguments, so moving it into a request
struct will reduce the churn of this internal API, make the plugin
code more readable, and make this method consistent with the other
plugin methods in that package.
The plugin supervisor lazily connects to plugins, but this means we
only get "Unavailable" back from the gRPC call in cases where the
plugin can never be reached (for example, if the Nomad client has the
wrong permissions for the socket).
This changeset improves the operator experience by switching to a
blocking `DialWithContext`. It eagerly connects so that we can
validate the connection is real and get a "failed to open" error in
case where Nomad can't establish the initial connection.
The CSI plugins RPCs require the use of the storage provider's volume
ID, rather than the user-defined volume ID. Although changing the RPCs
to use the field name `ExternalID` risks breaking backwards
compatibility, we can use the `ExternalID` name internally for the
client and only use `VolumeID` at the RPC boundaries.
CSI plugins can require credentials for some publishing and
unpublishing workflow RPCs. Secrets are configured at the time of
volume registration, stored in the volume struct, and then passed
around as an opaque map by Nomad to the plugins.
When serializing structs with msgpack, only consider type tags of
`codec`.
Hashicorp/go-msgpack (based on ugorji/go) defaults to interpretting
`codec` tag if it's available, but falls to using `json` if `codec`
isn't present.
This behavior is surprising in cases where we want to serialize json
differently from msgpack, e.g. serializing `ConsulExposeConfig`.
Several of the CSI `VolumeCapability` methods return pointers, which
we were then comparing to pointers in the request rather than
dereferencing them and comparing their contents.
This changeset does a more fine-grained comparison of the request vs
the capabilities, and adds better error messaging.
This changeset corrects handling of the `ValidationVolumeCapabilities`
response:
* The CSI spec for the `ValidationVolumeCapabilities` requires that
plugins only set the `Confirmed` field if they've validated all
capabilities. The Nomad client improperly assumes that the lack of a
`Confirmed` field should be treated as a failure. This breaks the
Azure and Linode block storage plugins, which don't set this
optional field.
* The CSI spec also requires that the orchestrator check the validation
responses to guard against older versions of a plugin reporting
"valid" for newer fields it doesn't understand.
The CSI Specification defines various gRPC Errors and how they may be retried. After auditing all our CSI RPC calls in #6863, this changeset:
* adds retries and backoffs to the where they were needed but not implemented
* annotates those CSI RPCs that do not need retries so that we don't wonder whether it's been left off accidentally
* added a timeout and cancellation context to the `Probe` call, which didn't have one.
Add mount_options to both the volume definition on registration and to the volume block in the group where the volume is requested. If both are specified, the options provided in the request replace the options defined in the volume. They get passed to the NodePublishVolume, which causes the node plugin to actually mount the volume on the host.
Individual tasks just mount bind into the host mounted volume (unchanged behavior). An operator can mount the same volume with different options by specifying it twice in the group context.
closes#7007
* nomad/structs/volumes: add MountOptions to volume request
* jobspec/test-fixtures/basic.hcl: add mount_options to volume block
* jobspec/parse_test: add expected MountOptions
* api/tasks: add mount_options
* jobspec/parse_group: use hcl decode not mapstructure, mount_options
* client/allocrunner/csi_hook: pass MountOptions through
client/allocrunner/csi_hook: add a VolumeMountOptions
client/allocrunner/csi_hook: drop Options
client/allocrunner/csi_hook: use the structs options
* client/pluginmanager/csimanager/interface: UsageOptions.MountOptions
* client/pluginmanager/csimanager/volume: pass MountOptions in capabilities
* plugins/csi/plugin: remove todo 7007 comment
* nomad/structs/csi: MountOptions
* api/csi: add options to the api for parsing, match structs
* plugins/csi/plugin: move VolumeMountOptions to structs
* api/csi: use specific type for mount_options
* client/allocrunner/csi_hook: merge MountOptions here
* rename CSIOptions to CSIMountOptions
* client/allocrunner/csi_hook
* client/pluginmanager/csimanager/volume
* nomad/structs/csi
* plugins/csi/fake/client: add PrevVolumeCapability
* plugins/csi/plugin
* client/pluginmanager/csimanager/volume_test: remove debugging
* client/pluginmanager/csimanager/volume: fix odd merging logic
* api: rename CSIOptions -> CSIMountOptions
* nomad/csi_endpoint: remove a 7007 comment
* command/alloc_status: show mount options in the volume list
* nomad/structs/csi: include MountOptions in the volume stub
* api/csi: add MountOptions to stub
* command/volume_status_csi: clean up csiVolMountOption, add it
* command/alloc_status: csiVolMountOption lives in volume_csi_status
* command/node_status: display mount flags
* nomad/structs/volumes: npe
* plugins/csi/plugin: npe in ToCSIRepresentation
* jobspec/parse_test: expand volume parse test cases
* command/agent/job_endpoint: ApiTgToStructsTG needs MountOptions
* command/volume_status_csi: copy paste error
* jobspec/test-fixtures/basic: hclfmt
* command/volume_status_csi: clean up csiVolMountOption
Run the plugin fingerprint one last time with a closed client during
instance manager shutdown. This will return quickly and will give us a
correctly-populated `PluginInfo` marked as unhealthy so the Nomad
client can update the server about plugin health.
Derive a provider name and version for plugins (and the volumes that
use them) from the CSI identity API `GetPluginInfo`. Expose the vendor
name as `Provider` in the API and CLI commands.
This changeset implements the minimal structs on the client-side we
need to compile the work-in-progress implementation of the
server-to-controller RPCs. It doesn't include implementing the
`ClientCSI.DettachVolume` RPC on the client.
This commit introduces a nomad model for interacting with CSI
VolumeCapabilities as a pre-requisite for implementing NodeStageVolume
and NodeMountVolume correctly.
These fields have a few special characteristics that I've tried to model
here - specificially, we make a basic attempt to avoid printing data
that should be redacted during debug logs (additional mount flags), and
also attempt to make debuggability of other integer fields easier by
implementing the fmt.Stringer and fmt.GoStringer interfaces as
necessary.
We do not currnetly implement a CSI Protobuf -> Nomad implementation
transformation as this is currently not needed by any used RPCs.
