// package balancer implements a custom gRPC load balancer. // // Similarly to gRPC's built-in "pick_first" balancer, our balancer will pin the // client to a single connection/server. However, it will switch servers as soon // as an RPC error occurs (e.g. if the client has exhausted its rate limit on // that server). It also provides a method that will be called periodically by // the Consul router to randomize the connection priorities to rebalance load. // // Our balancer aims to keep exactly one TCP connection (to the current server) // open at a time. This is different to gRPC's "round_robin" and "base" balancers // which connect to *all* resolved addresses up-front so that you can quickly // cycle between them - which we want to avoid because of the overhead on the // servers. It's also slightly different to gRPC's "pick_first" balancer which // will attempt to remain connected to the same server as long its address is // returned by the resolver - we previously had to work around this behavior in // order to shuffle the servers, which had some unfortunate side effects as // documented in this issue: https://github.com/hashicorp/consul/issues/10603. // // If a server is in a perpetually bad state, the balancer's standard error // handling will steer away from it but it will *not* be removed from the set // and will remain in a TRANSIENT_FAILURE state to possibly be retried in the // future. It is expected that Consul's router will remove servers from the // resolver which have been network partitioned etc. // // Quick primer on how gRPC's different components work together: // // - Targets (e.g. consul://.../server.dc1) represent endpoints/collections of // hosts. They're what you pass as the first argument to grpc.Dial. // // - ClientConns represent logical connections to targets. Each ClientConn may // have many SubConns (and therefore TCP connections to different hosts). // // - SubConns represent connections to a single host. They map 1:1 with TCP // connections (that's actually a bit of a lie, but true for our purposes). // // - Resolvers are responsible for turning Targets into sets of addresses (e.g. // via DNS resolution) and updating the ClientConn when they change. They map // 1:1 with ClientConns. gRPC creates them for a ClientConn using the builder // registered for the Target's scheme (i.e. the protocol part of the URL). // // - Balancers are responsible for turning resolved addresses into SubConns and // a Picker. They're called whenever the Resolver updates the ClientConn's // state (e.g. with new addresses) or when the SubConns change state. // // Like Resolvers, they also map 1:1 with ClientConns and are created using a // builder registered with a name that is specified in the "service config". // // - Pickers are responsible for deciding which SubConn will be used for an RPC. package balancer import ( "container/list" "errors" "fmt" "math/rand" "sort" "sync" "time" "github.com/hashicorp/go-hclog" gbalancer "google.golang.org/grpc/balancer" "google.golang.org/grpc/codes" "google.golang.org/grpc/connectivity" "google.golang.org/grpc/resolver" "google.golang.org/grpc/status" ) // NewBuilder constructs a new Builder with the given name. func NewBuilder(name string, logger hclog.Logger) *Builder { return &Builder{ name: name, logger: logger, byTarget: make(map[string]*list.List), shuffler: randomShuffler(), } } // Builder implements gRPC's balancer.Builder interface to construct balancers. type Builder struct { name string logger hclog.Logger shuffler shuffler mu sync.Mutex byTarget map[string]*list.List } // Build is called by gRPC (e.g. on grpc.Dial) to construct a balancer for the // given ClientConn. func (b *Builder) Build(cc gbalancer.ClientConn, opts gbalancer.BuildOptions) gbalancer.Balancer { b.mu.Lock() defer b.mu.Unlock() targetURL := opts.Target.URL.String() logger := b.logger.With("target", targetURL) logger.Trace("creating balancer") bal := newBalancer(cc, opts.Target, logger) byTarget, ok := b.byTarget[targetURL] if !ok { byTarget = list.New() b.byTarget[targetURL] = byTarget } elem := byTarget.PushBack(bal) bal.closeFn = func() { logger.Trace("removing balancer") b.removeBalancer(targetURL, elem) } return bal } // removeBalancer is called when a Balancer is closed to remove it from our list. func (b *Builder) removeBalancer(targetURL string, elem *list.Element) { b.mu.Lock() defer b.mu.Unlock() byTarget, ok := b.byTarget[targetURL] if !ok { return } byTarget.Remove(elem) if byTarget.Len() == 0 { delete(b.byTarget, targetURL) } } // Name implements the gRPC Balancer interface by returning its given name. func (b *Builder) Name() string { return b.name } // gRPC's balancer.Register method is not thread-safe, so we guard our calls // with a global lock (as it may be called from parallel tests). var registerLock sync.Mutex // Register the Builder in gRPC's global registry using its given name. func (b *Builder) Register() { registerLock.Lock() defer registerLock.Unlock() gbalancer.Register(b) } // Rebalance randomizes the priority order of servers for the given target to // rebalance load. func (b *Builder) Rebalance(target resolver.Target) { b.mu.Lock() defer b.mu.Unlock() byTarget, ok := b.byTarget[target.URL.String()] if !ok { return } for item := byTarget.Front(); item != nil; item = item.Next() { item.Value.(*balancer).shuffleServerOrder(b.shuffler) } } func newBalancer(conn gbalancer.ClientConn, target resolver.Target, logger hclog.Logger) *balancer { return &balancer{ conn: conn, target: target, logger: logger, servers: resolver.NewAddressMap(), } } type balancer struct { conn gbalancer.ClientConn target resolver.Target logger hclog.Logger closeFn func() mu sync.Mutex subConn gbalancer.SubConn connState connectivity.State connError error currentServer *serverInfo servers *resolver.AddressMap } type serverInfo struct { addr resolver.Address index int // determines the order in which servers will be attempted. lastFailed time.Time // used to steer away from servers that recently returned errors. } // String returns a log-friendly representation of the server. func (si *serverInfo) String() string { if si == nil { return "" } return si.addr.Addr } // Close is called by gRPC when the Balancer is no longer needed (e.g. when the // ClientConn is closed by the application). func (b *balancer) Close() { b.closeFn() } // ResolverError is called by gRPC when the resolver reports an error. It puts // the connection into a TRANSIENT_FAILURE state. func (b *balancer) ResolverError(err error) { b.mu.Lock() defer b.mu.Unlock() b.logger.Trace("resolver error", "error", err) b.handleErrorLocked(err) } // UpdateClientConnState is called by gRPC when the ClientConn changes state, // such as when the resolver produces new addresses. func (b *balancer) UpdateClientConnState(state gbalancer.ClientConnState) error { b.mu.Lock() defer b.mu.Unlock() newAddrs := resolver.NewAddressMap() // Add any new addresses. for _, addr := range state.ResolverState.Addresses { newAddrs.Set(addr, struct{}{}) if _, have := b.servers.Get(addr); !have { b.logger.Trace("adding server address", "address", addr.Addr) b.servers.Set(addr, &serverInfo{ addr: addr, index: b.servers.Len(), }) } } // Delete any addresses that have been removed. for _, addr := range b.servers.Keys() { if _, have := newAddrs.Get(addr); !have { b.logger.Trace("removing server address", "address", addr.Addr) b.servers.Delete(addr) } } if b.servers.Len() == 0 { b.switchServerLocked(nil) b.handleErrorLocked(errors.New("resolver produced no addresses")) return gbalancer.ErrBadResolverState } b.maybeSwitchServerLocked() return nil } // UpdateSubConnState is called by gRPC when a SubConn changes state, such as // when transitioning from CONNECTING to READY. func (b *balancer) UpdateSubConnState(sc gbalancer.SubConn, state gbalancer.SubConnState) { b.mu.Lock() defer b.mu.Unlock() if sc != b.subConn { return } b.logger.Trace("sub-connection state changed", "server", b.currentServer, "state", state.ConnectivityState) b.connState = state.ConnectivityState b.connError = state.ConnectionError // Note: it's not clear whether this can actually happen or not. It would mean // the sub-conn was shut down by something other than us calling RemoveSubConn. if state.ConnectivityState == connectivity.Shutdown { b.switchServerLocked(nil) return } b.updatePickerLocked() } // handleErrorLocked puts the ClientConn into a TRANSIENT_FAILURE state and // causes the picker to return the given error on Pick. // // Note: b.mu must be held when calling this method. func (b *balancer) handleErrorLocked(err error) { b.connState = connectivity.TransientFailure b.connError = fmt.Errorf("resolver error: %w", err) b.updatePickerLocked() } // maybeSwitchServerLocked switches server if the one we're currently connected // to is no longer our preference (e.g. based on error state). // // Note: b.mu must be held when calling this method. func (b *balancer) maybeSwitchServerLocked() { if ideal := b.idealServerLocked(); ideal != b.currentServer { b.switchServerLocked(ideal) } } // idealServerLocked determines which server we should currently be connected to // when taking the error state and rebalance-shuffling into consideration. // // Returns nil if there isn't a suitable server. // // Note: b.mu must be held when calling this method. func (b *balancer) idealServerLocked() *serverInfo { candidates := make([]*serverInfo, b.servers.Len()) for idx, v := range b.servers.Values() { candidates[idx] = v.(*serverInfo) } if len(candidates) == 0 { return nil } sort.Slice(candidates, func(a, b int) bool { ca, cb := candidates[a], candidates[b] return ca.lastFailed.Before(cb.lastFailed) || (ca.lastFailed.Equal(cb.lastFailed) && ca.index < cb.index) }) return candidates[0] } // switchServerLocked switches to the given server, creating a new connection // and tearing down the previous connection. // // It's expected for either/neither/both of b.currentServer and newServer to be nil. // // Note: b.mu must be held when calling this method. func (b *balancer) switchServerLocked(newServer *serverInfo) { b.logger.Debug("switching server", "from", b.currentServer, "to", newServer) prevConn := b.subConn b.currentServer = newServer if newServer == nil { b.subConn = nil } else { var err error b.subConn, err = b.conn.NewSubConn([]resolver.Address{newServer.addr}, gbalancer.NewSubConnOptions{}) if err == nil { b.subConn.Connect() b.connState = connectivity.Connecting } else { b.logger.Trace("failed to create sub-connection", "addr", newServer.addr, "error", err) b.handleErrorLocked(fmt.Errorf("failed to create sub-connection: %w", err)) return } } b.updatePickerLocked() if prevConn != nil { b.conn.RemoveSubConn(prevConn) } } // updatePickerLocked updates the ClientConn's Picker based on the balancer's // current state. // // Note: b.mu must be held when calling this method. func (b *balancer) updatePickerLocked() { var p gbalancer.Picker switch b.connState { case connectivity.Connecting: p = errPicker{err: gbalancer.ErrNoSubConnAvailable} case connectivity.TransientFailure: p = errPicker{err: b.connError} case connectivity.Idle: p = idlePicker{conn: b.subConn} case connectivity.Ready: srv := b.currentServer p = readyPicker{ conn: b.subConn, errFn: func(err error) { b.witnessError(srv, err) }, } default: // Note: shutdown state is handled in UpdateSubConnState. b.logger.Trace("connection in unexpected state", "state", b.connState) } b.conn.UpdateState(gbalancer.State{ ConnectivityState: b.connState, Picker: p, }) } // witnessError marks the given server as having failed and triggers a switch // if required. func (b *balancer) witnessError(server *serverInfo, err error) { // The following status codes represent errors that probably won't be solved // by switching servers, so we shouldn't bother disrupting in-flight streams. switch status.Code(err) { case codes.Canceled, codes.InvalidArgument, codes.NotFound, codes.AlreadyExists, codes.PermissionDenied, codes.Unauthenticated: return } b.mu.Lock() defer b.mu.Unlock() b.logger.Trace("witnessed RPC error", "server", server, "error", err) server.lastFailed = time.Now() b.maybeSwitchServerLocked() } // shuffleServerOrder re-prioritizes the servers using the given shuffler, it // also unsets the lastFailed timestamp (to prevent us *never* connecting to a // server that previously failed). func (b *balancer) shuffleServerOrder(shuffler shuffler) { b.mu.Lock() defer b.mu.Unlock() b.logger.Trace("shuffling server order") addrs := b.servers.Keys() shuffler(addrs) for idx, addr := range addrs { v, ok := b.servers.Get(addr) if !ok { continue } srv := v.(*serverInfo) srv.index = idx srv.lastFailed = time.Time{} } b.maybeSwitchServerLocked() } // errPicker returns the given error on Pick. type errPicker struct{ err error } func (p errPicker) Pick(gbalancer.PickInfo) (gbalancer.PickResult, error) { return gbalancer.PickResult{}, p.err } // idlePicker attempts to re-establish the given (idle) connection on Pick. type idlePicker struct{ conn gbalancer.SubConn } func (p idlePicker) Pick(gbalancer.PickInfo) (gbalancer.PickResult, error) { p.conn.Connect() return gbalancer.PickResult{}, gbalancer.ErrNoSubConnAvailable } // readyPicker returns the given connection on Pick. errFn will be called if // the RPC fails (i.e. to switch to another server). type readyPicker struct { conn gbalancer.SubConn errFn func(error) } func (p readyPicker) Pick(info gbalancer.PickInfo) (gbalancer.PickResult, error) { return gbalancer.PickResult{ SubConn: p.conn, Done: func(done gbalancer.DoneInfo) { if err := done.Err; err != nil { p.errFn(err) } }, }, nil } // shuffler is used to change the priority order of servers, to rebalance load. type shuffler func([]resolver.Address) // randomShuffler randomizes the priority order. func randomShuffler() shuffler { rand := rand.New(rand.NewSource(time.Now().UnixNano())) return func(addrs []resolver.Address) { rand.Shuffle(len(addrs), func(a, b int) { addrs[a], addrs[b] = addrs[b], addrs[a] }) } }