rocksdb/table/format.cc

710 lines
26 KiB
C++
Raw Normal View History

// Copyright (c) 2011-present, Facebook, Inc. All rights reserved.
// This source code is licensed under both the GPLv2 (found in the
// COPYING file in the root directory) and Apache 2.0 License
// (found in the LICENSE.Apache file in the root directory).
//
// Copyright (c) 2011 The LevelDB Authors. All rights reserved.
// Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style license that can be
// found in the LICENSE file. See the AUTHORS file for names of contributors.
#include "table/format.h"
#include <cinttypes>
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
#include <cstdint>
#include <string>
#include "block_fetcher.h"
#include "file/random_access_file_reader.h"
#include "memory/memory_allocator_impl.h"
#include "monitoring/perf_context_imp.h"
#include "monitoring/statistics_impl.h"
#include "options/options_helper.h"
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
#include "port/likely.h"
#include "rocksdb/env.h"
#include "rocksdb/options.h"
#include "rocksdb/table.h"
#include "table/block_based/block.h"
#include "table/block_based/block_based_table_reader.h"
#include "table/persistent_cache_helper.h"
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
#include "unique_id_impl.h"
#include "util/cast_util.h"
#include "util/coding.h"
#include "util/compression.h"
#include "util/crc32c.h"
#include "util/hash.h"
#include "util/stop_watch.h"
#include "util/string_util.h"
#include "util/xxhash.h"
namespace ROCKSDB_NAMESPACE {
const char* kHostnameForDbHostId = "__hostname__";
bool ShouldReportDetailedTime(Env* env, Statistics* stats) {
return env != nullptr && stats != nullptr &&
stats->get_stats_level() > kExceptDetailedTimers;
}
void BlockHandle::EncodeTo(std::string* dst) const {
// Sanity check that all fields have been set
assert(offset_ != ~uint64_t{0});
assert(size_ != ~uint64_t{0});
Miscellaneous performance improvements Summary: I was investigating performance issues in the SstFileWriter and found all of the following: - The SstFileWriter::Add() function created a local InternalKey every time it was called generating a allocation and free each time. Changed to have an InternalKey member variable that can be reset with the new InternalKey::Set() function. - In SstFileWriter::Add() the smallest_key and largest_key values were assigned the result of a ToString() call, but it is simpler to just assign them directly from the user's key. - The Slice class had no move constructor so each time one was returned from a function a new one had to be allocated, the old data copied to the new, and the old one was freed. I added the move constructor which also required a copy constructor and assignment operator. - The BlockBuilder::CurrentSizeEstimate() function calculates the current estimate size, but was being called 2 or 3 times for each key added. I changed the class to maintain a running estimate (equal to the original calculation) so that the function can return an already calculated value. - The code in BlockBuilder::Add() that calculated the shared bytes between the last key and the new key duplicated what Slice::difference_offset does, so I replaced it with the standard function. - BlockBuilder::Add() had code to copy just the changed portion into the last key value (and asserted that it now matched the new key). It is more efficient just to copy the whole new key over. - Moved this same code up into the 'if (use_delta_encoding_)' since the last key value is only needed when delta encoding is on. - FlushBlockBySizePolicy::BlockAlmostFull calculated a standard deviation value each time it was called, but this information would only change if block_size of block_size_deviation changed, so I created a member variable to hold the value to avoid the calculation each time. - Each PutVarint??() function has a buffer and calls std::string::append(). Two or three calls in a row could share a buffer and a single call to std::string::append(). Some of these will be helpful outside of the SstFileWriter. I'm not 100% the addition of the move constructor is appropriate as I wonder why this wasn't done before - maybe because of compiler compatibility? I tried it on gcc 4.8 and 4.9. Test Plan: The changes should not affect the results so the existing tests should all still work and no new tests were added. The value of the changes was seen by manually testing the SstFileWriter class through MyRocks and adding timing code to identify problem areas. Reviewers: sdong, IslamAbdelRahman Reviewed By: IslamAbdelRahman Subscribers: andrewkr, dhruba Differential Revision: https://reviews.facebook.net/D59607
2016-06-13 16:57:43 +00:00
PutVarint64Varint64(dst, offset_, size_);
}
char* BlockHandle::EncodeTo(char* dst) const {
// Sanity check that all fields have been set
assert(offset_ != ~uint64_t{0});
assert(size_ != ~uint64_t{0});
char* cur = EncodeVarint64(dst, offset_);
cur = EncodeVarint64(cur, size_);
return cur;
}
Status BlockHandle::DecodeFrom(Slice* input) {
if (GetVarint64(input, &offset_) && GetVarint64(input, &size_)) {
return Status::OK();
} else {
// reset in case failure after partially decoding
offset_ = 0;
size_ = 0;
return Status::Corruption("bad block handle");
}
}
Status BlockHandle::DecodeSizeFrom(uint64_t _offset, Slice* input) {
if (GetVarint64(input, &size_)) {
offset_ = _offset;
return Status::OK();
} else {
// reset in case failure after partially decoding
offset_ = 0;
size_ = 0;
return Status::Corruption("bad block handle");
}
}
// Return a string that contains the copy of handle.
std::string BlockHandle::ToString(bool hex) const {
std::string handle_str;
EncodeTo(&handle_str);
if (hex) {
return Slice(handle_str).ToString(true);
} else {
return handle_str;
}
}
const BlockHandle BlockHandle::kNullBlockHandle(0, 0);
Add an option to put first key of each sst block in the index (#5289) Summary: The first key is used to defer reading the data block until this file gets to the top of merging iterator's heap. For short range scans, most files never make it to the top of the heap, so this change can reduce read amplification by a lot sometimes. Consider the following workload. There are a few data streams (we'll be calling them "logs"), each stream consisting of a sequence of blobs (we'll be calling them "records"). Each record is identified by log ID and a sequence number within the log. RocksDB key is concatenation of log ID and sequence number (big endian). Reads are mostly relatively short range scans, each within a single log. Writes are mostly sequential for each log, but writes to different logs are randomly interleaved. Compactions are disabled; instead, when we accumulate a few tens of sst files, we create a new column family and start writing to it. So, a typical sst file consists of a few ranges of blocks, each range corresponding to one log ID (we use FlushBlockPolicy to cut blocks at log boundaries). A typical read would go like this. First, iterator Seek() reads one block from each sst file. Then a series of Next()s move through one sst file (since writes to each log are mostly sequential) until the subiterator reaches the end of this log in this sst file; then Next() switches to the next sst file and reads sequentially from that, and so on. Often a range scan will only return records from a small number of blocks in small number of sst files; in this case, the cost of initial Seek() reading one block from each file may be bigger than the cost of reading the actually useful blocks. Neither iterate_upper_bound nor bloom filters can prevent reading one block from each file in Seek(). But this PR can: if the index contains first key from each block, we don't have to read the block until this block actually makes it to the top of merging iterator's heap, so for short range scans we won't read any blocks from most of the sst files. This PR does the deferred block loading inside value() call. This is not ideal: there's no good way to report an IO error from inside value(). As discussed with siying offline, it would probably be better to change InternalIterator's interface to explicitly fetch deferred value and get status. I'll do it in a separate PR. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5289 Differential Revision: D15256423 Pulled By: al13n321 fbshipit-source-id: 750e4c39ce88e8d41662f701cf6275d9388ba46a
2019-06-25 03:50:35 +00:00
void IndexValue::EncodeTo(std::string* dst, bool have_first_key,
const BlockHandle* previous_handle) const {
if (previous_handle) {
Improve / clean up meta block code & integrity (#9163) Summary: * Checksums are now checked on meta blocks unless specifically suppressed or not applicable (e.g. plain table). (Was other way around.) This means a number of cases that were not checking checksums now are, including direct read TableProperties in Version::GetTableProperties (fixed in meta_blocks ReadTableProperties), reading any block from PersistentCache (fixed in BlockFetcher), read TableProperties in SstFileDumper (ldb/sst_dump/BackupEngine) before table reader open, maybe more. * For that to work, I moved the global_seqno+TableProperties checksum logic to the shared table/ code, because that is used by many utilies such as SstFileDumper. * Also for that to work, we have to know when we're dealing with a block that has a checksum (trailer), so added that capability to Footer based on magic number, and from there BlockFetcher. * Knowledge of trailer presence has also fixed a problem where other table formats were reading blocks including bytes for a non-existant trailer--and awkwardly kind-of not using them, e.g. no shared code checking checksums. (BlockFetcher compression type was populated incorrectly.) Now we only read what is needed. * Minimized code duplication and differing/incompatible/awkward abstractions in meta_blocks.{cc,h} (e.g. SeekTo in metaindex block without parsing block handle) * Moved some meta block handling code from table_properties*.* * Moved some code specific to block-based table from shared table/ code to BlockBasedTable class. The checksum stuff means we can't completely separate it, but things that don't need to be in shared table/ code should not be. * Use unique_ptr rather than raw ptr in more places. (Note: you can std::move from unique_ptr to shared_ptr.) Without enhancements to GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest (see below), net reduction of roughly 100 lines of code. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9163 Test Plan: existing tests and * Enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to verify that checksums are now checked on direct read of table properties by TableCache (new test would fail before this change) * Also enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to test putting table properties under old meta name * Also generally enhanced that same test to actually test what it was supposed to be testing already, by kicking things out of table cache when we don't want them there. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D32514757 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 507964b9311d186ae8d1131182290cbd97a99fa9
2021-11-18 19:42:12 +00:00
// WART: this is specific to Block-based table
Add an option to put first key of each sst block in the index (#5289) Summary: The first key is used to defer reading the data block until this file gets to the top of merging iterator's heap. For short range scans, most files never make it to the top of the heap, so this change can reduce read amplification by a lot sometimes. Consider the following workload. There are a few data streams (we'll be calling them "logs"), each stream consisting of a sequence of blobs (we'll be calling them "records"). Each record is identified by log ID and a sequence number within the log. RocksDB key is concatenation of log ID and sequence number (big endian). Reads are mostly relatively short range scans, each within a single log. Writes are mostly sequential for each log, but writes to different logs are randomly interleaved. Compactions are disabled; instead, when we accumulate a few tens of sst files, we create a new column family and start writing to it. So, a typical sst file consists of a few ranges of blocks, each range corresponding to one log ID (we use FlushBlockPolicy to cut blocks at log boundaries). A typical read would go like this. First, iterator Seek() reads one block from each sst file. Then a series of Next()s move through one sst file (since writes to each log are mostly sequential) until the subiterator reaches the end of this log in this sst file; then Next() switches to the next sst file and reads sequentially from that, and so on. Often a range scan will only return records from a small number of blocks in small number of sst files; in this case, the cost of initial Seek() reading one block from each file may be bigger than the cost of reading the actually useful blocks. Neither iterate_upper_bound nor bloom filters can prevent reading one block from each file in Seek(). But this PR can: if the index contains first key from each block, we don't have to read the block until this block actually makes it to the top of merging iterator's heap, so for short range scans we won't read any blocks from most of the sst files. This PR does the deferred block loading inside value() call. This is not ideal: there's no good way to report an IO error from inside value(). As discussed with siying offline, it would probably be better to change InternalIterator's interface to explicitly fetch deferred value and get status. I'll do it in a separate PR. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5289 Differential Revision: D15256423 Pulled By: al13n321 fbshipit-source-id: 750e4c39ce88e8d41662f701cf6275d9388ba46a
2019-06-25 03:50:35 +00:00
assert(handle.offset() == previous_handle->offset() +
Improve / clean up meta block code & integrity (#9163) Summary: * Checksums are now checked on meta blocks unless specifically suppressed or not applicable (e.g. plain table). (Was other way around.) This means a number of cases that were not checking checksums now are, including direct read TableProperties in Version::GetTableProperties (fixed in meta_blocks ReadTableProperties), reading any block from PersistentCache (fixed in BlockFetcher), read TableProperties in SstFileDumper (ldb/sst_dump/BackupEngine) before table reader open, maybe more. * For that to work, I moved the global_seqno+TableProperties checksum logic to the shared table/ code, because that is used by many utilies such as SstFileDumper. * Also for that to work, we have to know when we're dealing with a block that has a checksum (trailer), so added that capability to Footer based on magic number, and from there BlockFetcher. * Knowledge of trailer presence has also fixed a problem where other table formats were reading blocks including bytes for a non-existant trailer--and awkwardly kind-of not using them, e.g. no shared code checking checksums. (BlockFetcher compression type was populated incorrectly.) Now we only read what is needed. * Minimized code duplication and differing/incompatible/awkward abstractions in meta_blocks.{cc,h} (e.g. SeekTo in metaindex block without parsing block handle) * Moved some meta block handling code from table_properties*.* * Moved some code specific to block-based table from shared table/ code to BlockBasedTable class. The checksum stuff means we can't completely separate it, but things that don't need to be in shared table/ code should not be. * Use unique_ptr rather than raw ptr in more places. (Note: you can std::move from unique_ptr to shared_ptr.) Without enhancements to GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest (see below), net reduction of roughly 100 lines of code. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9163 Test Plan: existing tests and * Enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to verify that checksums are now checked on direct read of table properties by TableCache (new test would fail before this change) * Also enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to test putting table properties under old meta name * Also generally enhanced that same test to actually test what it was supposed to be testing already, by kicking things out of table cache when we don't want them there. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D32514757 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 507964b9311d186ae8d1131182290cbd97a99fa9
2021-11-18 19:42:12 +00:00
previous_handle->size() +
BlockBasedTable::kBlockTrailerSize);
Add an option to put first key of each sst block in the index (#5289) Summary: The first key is used to defer reading the data block until this file gets to the top of merging iterator's heap. For short range scans, most files never make it to the top of the heap, so this change can reduce read amplification by a lot sometimes. Consider the following workload. There are a few data streams (we'll be calling them "logs"), each stream consisting of a sequence of blobs (we'll be calling them "records"). Each record is identified by log ID and a sequence number within the log. RocksDB key is concatenation of log ID and sequence number (big endian). Reads are mostly relatively short range scans, each within a single log. Writes are mostly sequential for each log, but writes to different logs are randomly interleaved. Compactions are disabled; instead, when we accumulate a few tens of sst files, we create a new column family and start writing to it. So, a typical sst file consists of a few ranges of blocks, each range corresponding to one log ID (we use FlushBlockPolicy to cut blocks at log boundaries). A typical read would go like this. First, iterator Seek() reads one block from each sst file. Then a series of Next()s move through one sst file (since writes to each log are mostly sequential) until the subiterator reaches the end of this log in this sst file; then Next() switches to the next sst file and reads sequentially from that, and so on. Often a range scan will only return records from a small number of blocks in small number of sst files; in this case, the cost of initial Seek() reading one block from each file may be bigger than the cost of reading the actually useful blocks. Neither iterate_upper_bound nor bloom filters can prevent reading one block from each file in Seek(). But this PR can: if the index contains first key from each block, we don't have to read the block until this block actually makes it to the top of merging iterator's heap, so for short range scans we won't read any blocks from most of the sst files. This PR does the deferred block loading inside value() call. This is not ideal: there's no good way to report an IO error from inside value(). As discussed with siying offline, it would probably be better to change InternalIterator's interface to explicitly fetch deferred value and get status. I'll do it in a separate PR. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5289 Differential Revision: D15256423 Pulled By: al13n321 fbshipit-source-id: 750e4c39ce88e8d41662f701cf6275d9388ba46a
2019-06-25 03:50:35 +00:00
PutVarsignedint64(dst, handle.size() - previous_handle->size());
} else {
handle.EncodeTo(dst);
}
assert(dst->size() != 0);
if (have_first_key) {
PutLengthPrefixedSlice(dst, first_internal_key);
}
}
Status IndexValue::DecodeFrom(Slice* input, bool have_first_key,
const BlockHandle* previous_handle) {
if (previous_handle) {
int64_t delta;
if (!GetVarsignedint64(input, &delta)) {
return Status::Corruption("bad delta-encoded index value");
}
Improve / clean up meta block code & integrity (#9163) Summary: * Checksums are now checked on meta blocks unless specifically suppressed or not applicable (e.g. plain table). (Was other way around.) This means a number of cases that were not checking checksums now are, including direct read TableProperties in Version::GetTableProperties (fixed in meta_blocks ReadTableProperties), reading any block from PersistentCache (fixed in BlockFetcher), read TableProperties in SstFileDumper (ldb/sst_dump/BackupEngine) before table reader open, maybe more. * For that to work, I moved the global_seqno+TableProperties checksum logic to the shared table/ code, because that is used by many utilies such as SstFileDumper. * Also for that to work, we have to know when we're dealing with a block that has a checksum (trailer), so added that capability to Footer based on magic number, and from there BlockFetcher. * Knowledge of trailer presence has also fixed a problem where other table formats were reading blocks including bytes for a non-existant trailer--and awkwardly kind-of not using them, e.g. no shared code checking checksums. (BlockFetcher compression type was populated incorrectly.) Now we only read what is needed. * Minimized code duplication and differing/incompatible/awkward abstractions in meta_blocks.{cc,h} (e.g. SeekTo in metaindex block without parsing block handle) * Moved some meta block handling code from table_properties*.* * Moved some code specific to block-based table from shared table/ code to BlockBasedTable class. The checksum stuff means we can't completely separate it, but things that don't need to be in shared table/ code should not be. * Use unique_ptr rather than raw ptr in more places. (Note: you can std::move from unique_ptr to shared_ptr.) Without enhancements to GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest (see below), net reduction of roughly 100 lines of code. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9163 Test Plan: existing tests and * Enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to verify that checksums are now checked on direct read of table properties by TableCache (new test would fail before this change) * Also enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to test putting table properties under old meta name * Also generally enhanced that same test to actually test what it was supposed to be testing already, by kicking things out of table cache when we don't want them there. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D32514757 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 507964b9311d186ae8d1131182290cbd97a99fa9
2021-11-18 19:42:12 +00:00
// WART: this is specific to Block-based table
handle = BlockHandle(previous_handle->offset() + previous_handle->size() +
BlockBasedTable::kBlockTrailerSize,
previous_handle->size() + delta);
Add an option to put first key of each sst block in the index (#5289) Summary: The first key is used to defer reading the data block until this file gets to the top of merging iterator's heap. For short range scans, most files never make it to the top of the heap, so this change can reduce read amplification by a lot sometimes. Consider the following workload. There are a few data streams (we'll be calling them "logs"), each stream consisting of a sequence of blobs (we'll be calling them "records"). Each record is identified by log ID and a sequence number within the log. RocksDB key is concatenation of log ID and sequence number (big endian). Reads are mostly relatively short range scans, each within a single log. Writes are mostly sequential for each log, but writes to different logs are randomly interleaved. Compactions are disabled; instead, when we accumulate a few tens of sst files, we create a new column family and start writing to it. So, a typical sst file consists of a few ranges of blocks, each range corresponding to one log ID (we use FlushBlockPolicy to cut blocks at log boundaries). A typical read would go like this. First, iterator Seek() reads one block from each sst file. Then a series of Next()s move through one sst file (since writes to each log are mostly sequential) until the subiterator reaches the end of this log in this sst file; then Next() switches to the next sst file and reads sequentially from that, and so on. Often a range scan will only return records from a small number of blocks in small number of sst files; in this case, the cost of initial Seek() reading one block from each file may be bigger than the cost of reading the actually useful blocks. Neither iterate_upper_bound nor bloom filters can prevent reading one block from each file in Seek(). But this PR can: if the index contains first key from each block, we don't have to read the block until this block actually makes it to the top of merging iterator's heap, so for short range scans we won't read any blocks from most of the sst files. This PR does the deferred block loading inside value() call. This is not ideal: there's no good way to report an IO error from inside value(). As discussed with siying offline, it would probably be better to change InternalIterator's interface to explicitly fetch deferred value and get status. I'll do it in a separate PR. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5289 Differential Revision: D15256423 Pulled By: al13n321 fbshipit-source-id: 750e4c39ce88e8d41662f701cf6275d9388ba46a
2019-06-25 03:50:35 +00:00
} else {
Status s = handle.DecodeFrom(input);
if (!s.ok()) {
return s;
}
}
if (!have_first_key) {
first_internal_key = Slice();
} else if (!GetLengthPrefixedSlice(input, &first_internal_key)) {
return Status::Corruption("bad first key in block info");
}
return Status::OK();
}
std::string IndexValue::ToString(bool hex, bool have_first_key) const {
std::string s;
EncodeTo(&s, have_first_key, nullptr);
if (hex) {
return Slice(s).ToString(true);
} else {
return s;
}
}
namespace {
inline bool IsLegacyFooterFormat(uint64_t magic_number) {
return magic_number == kLegacyBlockBasedTableMagicNumber ||
magic_number == kLegacyPlainTableMagicNumber;
}
inline uint64_t UpconvertLegacyFooterFormat(uint64_t magic_number) {
if (magic_number == kLegacyBlockBasedTableMagicNumber) {
return kBlockBasedTableMagicNumber;
}
if (magic_number == kLegacyPlainTableMagicNumber) {
return kPlainTableMagicNumber;
}
assert(false);
return magic_number;
}
inline uint64_t DownconvertToLegacyFooterFormat(uint64_t magic_number) {
if (magic_number == kBlockBasedTableMagicNumber) {
return kLegacyBlockBasedTableMagicNumber;
}
if (magic_number == kPlainTableMagicNumber) {
return kLegacyPlainTableMagicNumber;
}
assert(false);
return magic_number;
}
inline uint8_t BlockTrailerSizeForMagicNumber(uint64_t magic_number) {
Improve / clean up meta block code & integrity (#9163) Summary: * Checksums are now checked on meta blocks unless specifically suppressed or not applicable (e.g. plain table). (Was other way around.) This means a number of cases that were not checking checksums now are, including direct read TableProperties in Version::GetTableProperties (fixed in meta_blocks ReadTableProperties), reading any block from PersistentCache (fixed in BlockFetcher), read TableProperties in SstFileDumper (ldb/sst_dump/BackupEngine) before table reader open, maybe more. * For that to work, I moved the global_seqno+TableProperties checksum logic to the shared table/ code, because that is used by many utilies such as SstFileDumper. * Also for that to work, we have to know when we're dealing with a block that has a checksum (trailer), so added that capability to Footer based on magic number, and from there BlockFetcher. * Knowledge of trailer presence has also fixed a problem where other table formats were reading blocks including bytes for a non-existant trailer--and awkwardly kind-of not using them, e.g. no shared code checking checksums. (BlockFetcher compression type was populated incorrectly.) Now we only read what is needed. * Minimized code duplication and differing/incompatible/awkward abstractions in meta_blocks.{cc,h} (e.g. SeekTo in metaindex block without parsing block handle) * Moved some meta block handling code from table_properties*.* * Moved some code specific to block-based table from shared table/ code to BlockBasedTable class. The checksum stuff means we can't completely separate it, but things that don't need to be in shared table/ code should not be. * Use unique_ptr rather than raw ptr in more places. (Note: you can std::move from unique_ptr to shared_ptr.) Without enhancements to GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest (see below), net reduction of roughly 100 lines of code. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9163 Test Plan: existing tests and * Enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to verify that checksums are now checked on direct read of table properties by TableCache (new test would fail before this change) * Also enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to test putting table properties under old meta name * Also generally enhanced that same test to actually test what it was supposed to be testing already, by kicking things out of table cache when we don't want them there. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D32514757 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 507964b9311d186ae8d1131182290cbd97a99fa9
2021-11-18 19:42:12 +00:00
if (magic_number == kBlockBasedTableMagicNumber ||
magic_number == kLegacyBlockBasedTableMagicNumber) {
return static_cast<uint8_t>(BlockBasedTable::kBlockTrailerSize);
Improve / clean up meta block code & integrity (#9163) Summary: * Checksums are now checked on meta blocks unless specifically suppressed or not applicable (e.g. plain table). (Was other way around.) This means a number of cases that were not checking checksums now are, including direct read TableProperties in Version::GetTableProperties (fixed in meta_blocks ReadTableProperties), reading any block from PersistentCache (fixed in BlockFetcher), read TableProperties in SstFileDumper (ldb/sst_dump/BackupEngine) before table reader open, maybe more. * For that to work, I moved the global_seqno+TableProperties checksum logic to the shared table/ code, because that is used by many utilies such as SstFileDumper. * Also for that to work, we have to know when we're dealing with a block that has a checksum (trailer), so added that capability to Footer based on magic number, and from there BlockFetcher. * Knowledge of trailer presence has also fixed a problem where other table formats were reading blocks including bytes for a non-existant trailer--and awkwardly kind-of not using them, e.g. no shared code checking checksums. (BlockFetcher compression type was populated incorrectly.) Now we only read what is needed. * Minimized code duplication and differing/incompatible/awkward abstractions in meta_blocks.{cc,h} (e.g. SeekTo in metaindex block without parsing block handle) * Moved some meta block handling code from table_properties*.* * Moved some code specific to block-based table from shared table/ code to BlockBasedTable class. The checksum stuff means we can't completely separate it, but things that don't need to be in shared table/ code should not be. * Use unique_ptr rather than raw ptr in more places. (Note: you can std::move from unique_ptr to shared_ptr.) Without enhancements to GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest (see below), net reduction of roughly 100 lines of code. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9163 Test Plan: existing tests and * Enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to verify that checksums are now checked on direct read of table properties by TableCache (new test would fail before this change) * Also enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to test putting table properties under old meta name * Also generally enhanced that same test to actually test what it was supposed to be testing already, by kicking things out of table cache when we don't want them there. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D32514757 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 507964b9311d186ae8d1131182290cbd97a99fa9
2021-11-18 19:42:12 +00:00
} else {
return 0;
Improve / clean up meta block code & integrity (#9163) Summary: * Checksums are now checked on meta blocks unless specifically suppressed or not applicable (e.g. plain table). (Was other way around.) This means a number of cases that were not checking checksums now are, including direct read TableProperties in Version::GetTableProperties (fixed in meta_blocks ReadTableProperties), reading any block from PersistentCache (fixed in BlockFetcher), read TableProperties in SstFileDumper (ldb/sst_dump/BackupEngine) before table reader open, maybe more. * For that to work, I moved the global_seqno+TableProperties checksum logic to the shared table/ code, because that is used by many utilies such as SstFileDumper. * Also for that to work, we have to know when we're dealing with a block that has a checksum (trailer), so added that capability to Footer based on magic number, and from there BlockFetcher. * Knowledge of trailer presence has also fixed a problem where other table formats were reading blocks including bytes for a non-existant trailer--and awkwardly kind-of not using them, e.g. no shared code checking checksums. (BlockFetcher compression type was populated incorrectly.) Now we only read what is needed. * Minimized code duplication and differing/incompatible/awkward abstractions in meta_blocks.{cc,h} (e.g. SeekTo in metaindex block without parsing block handle) * Moved some meta block handling code from table_properties*.* * Moved some code specific to block-based table from shared table/ code to BlockBasedTable class. The checksum stuff means we can't completely separate it, but things that don't need to be in shared table/ code should not be. * Use unique_ptr rather than raw ptr in more places. (Note: you can std::move from unique_ptr to shared_ptr.) Without enhancements to GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest (see below), net reduction of roughly 100 lines of code. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9163 Test Plan: existing tests and * Enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to verify that checksums are now checked on direct read of table properties by TableCache (new test would fail before this change) * Also enhanced DBTablePropertiesTest.GetPropertiesOfAllTablesTest to test putting table properties under old meta name * Also generally enhanced that same test to actually test what it was supposed to be testing already, by kicking things out of table cache when we don't want them there. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D32514757 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 507964b9311d186ae8d1131182290cbd97a99fa9
2021-11-18 19:42:12 +00:00
}
}
// Footer format, in three parts:
// * Part1
// -> format_version == 0 (inferred from legacy magic number)
// <empty> (0 bytes)
// -> format_version >= 1
// checksum type (char, 1 byte)
// * Part2
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
// -> format_version <= 5
// metaindex handle (varint64 offset, varint64 size)
// index handle (varint64 offset, varint64 size)
// <zero padding> for part2 size = 2 * BlockHandle::kMaxEncodedLength = 40
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
// - This padding is unchecked/ignored
// -> format_version >= 6
// extended magic number (4 bytes) = 0x3e 0x00 0x7a 0x00
// - Also surely invalid (size 0) handles if interpreted as older version
// - (Helps ensure a corrupted format_version doesn't get us far with no
// footer checksum.)
// footer_checksum (uint32LE, 4 bytes)
// - Checksum of above checksum type of whole footer, with this field
// set to all zeros.
// base_context_checksum (uint32LE, 4 bytes)
// metaindex block size (uint32LE, 4 bytes)
// - Assumed to be immediately before footer, < 4GB
// <zero padding> (24 bytes, reserved for future use)
// - Brings part2 size also to 40 bytes
// - Checked that last eight bytes == 0, so reserved for a future
// incompatible feature (but under format_version=6)
// * Part3
// -> format_version == 0 (inferred from legacy magic number)
// legacy magic number (8 bytes)
// -> format_version >= 1 (inferred from NOT legacy magic number)
// format_version (uint32LE, 4 bytes), also called "footer version"
// newer magic number (8 bytes)
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
const std::array<char, 4> kExtendedMagic{{0x3e, 0x00, 0x7a, 0x00}};
constexpr size_t kFooterPart2Size = 2 * BlockHandle::kMaxEncodedLength;
} // namespace
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
Status FooterBuilder::Build(uint64_t magic_number, uint32_t format_version,
uint64_t footer_offset, ChecksumType checksum_type,
const BlockHandle& metaindex_handle,
const BlockHandle& index_handle,
uint32_t base_context_checksum) {
assert(magic_number != Footer::kNullTableMagicNumber);
assert(IsSupportedFormatVersion(format_version));
char* part2;
char* part3;
if (format_version > 0) {
slice_ = Slice(data_.data(), Footer::kNewVersionsEncodedLength);
// Generate parts 1 and 3
char* cur = data_.data();
// Part 1
*(cur++) = checksum_type;
// Part 2
part2 = cur;
// Skip over part 2 for now
cur += kFooterPart2Size;
// Part 3
part3 = cur;
EncodeFixed32(cur, format_version);
cur += 4;
EncodeFixed64(cur, magic_number);
assert(cur + 8 == slice_.data() + slice_.size());
} else {
slice_ = Slice(data_.data(), Footer::kVersion0EncodedLength);
// Legacy SST files use kCRC32c checksum but it's not stored in footer.
assert(checksum_type == kNoChecksum || checksum_type == kCRC32c);
// Generate part 3 (part 1 empty, skip part 2 for now)
part2 = data_.data();
part3 = part2 + kFooterPart2Size;
char* cur = part3;
// Use legacy magic numbers to indicate format_version=0, for
// compatibility. No other cases should use format_version=0.
EncodeFixed64(cur, DownconvertToLegacyFooterFormat(magic_number));
assert(cur + 8 == slice_.data() + slice_.size());
}
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
if (format_version >= 6) {
if (BlockTrailerSizeForMagicNumber(magic_number) != 0) {
// base context checksum required for table formats with block checksums
assert(base_context_checksum != 0);
assert(ChecksumModifierForContext(base_context_checksum, 0) != 0);
} else {
// base context checksum not used
assert(base_context_checksum == 0);
assert(ChecksumModifierForContext(base_context_checksum, 0) == 0);
}
// Start populating Part 2
char* cur = data_.data() + /* part 1 size */ 1;
// Set extended magic of part2
std::copy(kExtendedMagic.begin(), kExtendedMagic.end(), cur);
cur += kExtendedMagic.size();
// Fill checksum data with zeros (for later computing checksum)
char* checksum_data = cur;
EncodeFixed32(cur, 0);
cur += 4;
// Save base context checksum
EncodeFixed32(cur, base_context_checksum);
cur += 4;
// Compute and save metaindex size
uint32_t metaindex_size = static_cast<uint32_t>(metaindex_handle.size());
if (metaindex_size != metaindex_handle.size()) {
return Status::NotSupported("Metaindex block size > 4GB");
}
// Metaindex must be adjacent to footer
assert(metaindex_size == 0 ||
metaindex_handle.offset() + metaindex_handle.size() ==
footer_offset - BlockTrailerSizeForMagicNumber(magic_number));
EncodeFixed32(cur, metaindex_size);
cur += 4;
// Zero pad remainder (for future use)
std::fill_n(cur, 24U, char{0});
assert(cur + 24 == part3);
// Compute checksum, add context
uint32_t checksum = ComputeBuiltinChecksum(
checksum_type, data_.data(), Footer::kNewVersionsEncodedLength);
checksum +=
ChecksumModifierForContext(base_context_checksum, footer_offset);
// Store it
EncodeFixed32(checksum_data, checksum);
} else {
// Base context checksum not used
assert(!FormatVersionUsesContextChecksum(format_version));
// Should be left empty
assert(base_context_checksum == 0);
assert(ChecksumModifierForContext(base_context_checksum, 0) == 0);
// Populate all of part 2
char* cur = part2;
cur = metaindex_handle.EncodeTo(cur);
cur = index_handle.EncodeTo(cur);
// Zero pad remainder
std::fill(cur, part3, char{0});
}
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
return Status::OK();
}
Status Footer::DecodeFrom(Slice input, uint64_t input_offset,
uint64_t enforce_table_magic_number) {
// Only decode to unused Footer
assert(table_magic_number_ == kNullTableMagicNumber);
assert(input != nullptr);
assert(input.size() >= kMinEncodedLength);
const char* magic_ptr = input.data() + input.size() - kMagicNumberLengthByte;
uint64_t magic = DecodeFixed64(magic_ptr);
// We check for legacy formats here and silently upconvert them
bool legacy = IsLegacyFooterFormat(magic);
if (legacy) {
magic = UpconvertLegacyFooterFormat(magic);
}
if (enforce_table_magic_number != 0 && enforce_table_magic_number != magic) {
return Status::Corruption("Bad table magic number: expected " +
std::to_string(enforce_table_magic_number) +
", found " + std::to_string(magic));
}
table_magic_number_ = magic;
block_trailer_size_ = BlockTrailerSizeForMagicNumber(magic);
// Parse Part3
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
const char* part3_ptr = magic_ptr;
uint32_t computed_checksum = 0;
uint64_t footer_offset = 0;
if (legacy) {
// The size is already asserted to be at least kMinEncodedLength
// at the beginning of the function
input.remove_prefix(input.size() - kVersion0EncodedLength);
format_version_ = 0 /* legacy */;
checksum_type_ = kCRC32c;
} else {
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
part3_ptr = magic_ptr - 4;
format_version_ = DecodeFixed32(part3_ptr);
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
if (UNLIKELY(!IsSupportedFormatVersion(format_version_))) {
return Status::Corruption("Corrupt or unsupported format_version: " +
std::to_string(format_version_));
}
// All known format versions >= 1 occupy exactly this many bytes.
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
if (UNLIKELY(input.size() < kNewVersionsEncodedLength)) {
return Status::Corruption("Input is too short to be an SST file");
}
uint64_t adjustment = input.size() - kNewVersionsEncodedLength;
input.remove_prefix(adjustment);
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
footer_offset = input_offset + adjustment;
// Parse Part1
char chksum = input.data()[0];
checksum_type_ = lossless_cast<ChecksumType>(chksum);
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
if (UNLIKELY(!IsSupportedChecksumType(checksum_type()))) {
return Status::Corruption("Corrupt or unsupported checksum type: " +
std::to_string(lossless_cast<uint8_t>(chksum)));
}
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
// This is the most convenient place to compute the checksum
if (checksum_type_ != kNoChecksum && format_version_ >= 6) {
std::array<char, kNewVersionsEncodedLength> copy_without_checksum;
std::copy_n(input.data(), kNewVersionsEncodedLength,
copy_without_checksum.data());
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
EncodeFixed32(&copy_without_checksum[5], 0); // Clear embedded checksum
computed_checksum =
ComputeBuiltinChecksum(checksum_type(), copy_without_checksum.data(),
kNewVersionsEncodedLength);
}
// Consume checksum type field
input.remove_prefix(1);
}
// Parse Part2
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
if (format_version_ >= 6) {
Slice ext_magic(input.data(), 4);
if (UNLIKELY(ext_magic.compare(Slice(kExtendedMagic.data(),
kExtendedMagic.size())) != 0)) {
return Status::Corruption("Bad extended magic number: 0x" +
ext_magic.ToString(/*hex*/ true));
}
input.remove_prefix(4);
uint32_t stored_checksum = 0, metaindex_size = 0;
bool success;
success = GetFixed32(&input, &stored_checksum);
assert(success);
success = GetFixed32(&input, &base_context_checksum_);
assert(success);
if (UNLIKELY(ChecksumModifierForContext(base_context_checksum_, 0) == 0)) {
return Status::Corruption("Invalid base context checksum");
}
computed_checksum +=
ChecksumModifierForContext(base_context_checksum_, footer_offset);
if (UNLIKELY(computed_checksum != stored_checksum)) {
return Status::Corruption("Footer at " + std::to_string(footer_offset) +
" checksum mismatch");
}
success = GetFixed32(&input, &metaindex_size);
assert(success);
(void)success;
uint64_t metaindex_end = footer_offset - GetBlockTrailerSize();
metaindex_handle_ =
BlockHandle(metaindex_end - metaindex_size, metaindex_size);
// Mark unpopulated
index_handle_ = BlockHandle::NullBlockHandle();
// 16 bytes of unchecked reserved padding
input.remove_prefix(16U);
// 8 bytes of checked reserved padding (expected to be zero unless using a
// future feature).
uint64_t reserved = 0;
success = GetFixed64(&input, &reserved);
assert(success);
if (UNLIKELY(reserved != 0)) {
return Status::NotSupported(
"File uses a future feature not supported in this version");
}
// End of part 2
assert(input.data() == part3_ptr);
} else {
// format_version_ < 6
Status result = metaindex_handle_.DecodeFrom(&input);
if (result.ok()) {
result = index_handle_.DecodeFrom(&input);
}
if (!result.ok()) {
return result;
}
// Padding in part2 is ignored
}
format_version=6 and context-aware block checksums (#9058) Summary: ## Context checksum All RocksDB checksums currently use 32 bits of checking power, which should be 1 in 4 billion false negative (FN) probability (failing to detect corruption). This is true for random corruptions, and in some cases small corruptions are guaranteed to be detected. But some possible corruptions, such as in storage metadata rather than storage payload data, would have a much higher FN rate. For example: * Data larger than one SST block is replaced by data from elsewhere in the same or another SST file. Especially with block_align=true, the probability of exact block size match is probably around 1 in 100, making the FN probability around that same. Without `block_align=true` the probability of same block start location is probably around 1 in 10,000, for FN probability around 1 in a million. To solve this problem in new format_version=6, we add "context awareness" to block checksum checks. The stored and expected checksum value is modified based on the block's position in the file and which file it is in. The modifications are cleverly chosen so that, for example * blocks within about 4GB of each other are guaranteed to use different context * blocks that are offset by exactly some multiple of 4GiB are guaranteed to use different context * files generated by the same process are guaranteed to use different context for the same offsets, until wrap-around after 2^32 - 1 files Thus, with format_version=6, if a valid SST block and checksum is misplaced, its checksum FN probability should be essentially ideal, 1 in 4B. ## Footer checksum This change also adds checksum protection to the SST footer (with format_version=6), for the first time without relying on whole file checksum. To prevent a corruption of the format_version in the footer (e.g. 6 -> 5) to defeat the footer checksum, we change much of the footer data format including an "extended magic number" in format_version 6 that would be interpreted as empty index and metaindex block handles in older footer versions. We also change the encoding of handles to free up space for other new data in footer. ## More detail: making space in footer In order to keep footer the same size in format_version=6 (avoid change to IO patterns), we have to free up some space for new data. We do this two ways: * Metaindex block handle is encoded down to 4 bytes (from 10) by assuming it immediately precedes the footer, and by assuming it is < 4GB. * Index block handle is moved into metaindex. (I don't know why it was in footer to begin with.) ## Performance In case of small performance penalty, I've made a "pay as you go" optimization to compensate: replace `MutableCFOptions` in BlockBasedTableBuilder::Rep with the only field used in that structure after construction: `prefix_extractor`. This makes the PR an overall performance improvement (results below). Nevertheless I'm seeing essentially no difference going from fv=5 to fv=6, even including that improvement for both. That's based on extreme case table write performance testing, many files with many blocks. This is relatively checksum intensive (small blocks) and salt generation intensive (small files). ``` (for I in `seq 1 100`; do TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/dbbench2 ./db_bench -benchmarks=fillseq -memtablerep=vector -disable_wal=1 -allow_concurrent_memtable_write=false -num=3000000 -compaction_style=2 -fifo_compaction_max_table_files_size_mb=10000 -fifo_compaction_allow_compaction=0 -write_buffer_size=100000 -compression_type=none -block_size=1000; done) 2>&1 | grep micros/op | tee out awk '{ tot += $5; n += 1; } END { print int(1.0 * tot / n) }' < out ``` Each value below is ops/s averaged over 100 runs, run simultaneously with competing configuration for load fairness Before -> after (both fv=5): 483530 -> 483673 (negligible) Re-run 1: 480733 -> 485427 (1.0% faster) Re-run 2: 483821 -> 484541 (0.1% faster) Before (fv=5) -> after (fv=6): 482006 -> 485100 (0.6% faster) Re-run 1: 482212 -> 485075 (0.6% faster) Re-run 2: 483590 -> 484073 (0.1% faster) After fv=5 -> after fv=6: 483878 -> 485542 (0.3% faster) Re-run 1: 485331 -> 483385 (0.4% slower) Re-run 2: 485283 -> 483435 (0.4% slower) Re-run 3: 483647 -> 486109 (0.5% faster) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9058 Test Plan: unit tests included (table_test, db_properties_test, salt in env_test). General DB tests and crash test updated to test new format_version. Also temporarily updated the default format version to 6 and saw some test failures. Almost all were due to an inadvertent additional read in VerifyChecksum to verify the index block checksum, though it's arguably a bug that VerifyChecksum does not appear to (re-)verify the index block checksum, just assuming it was verified in opening the index reader (probably *usually* true but probably not always true). Some other concerns about VerifyChecksum are left in FIXME comments. The only remaining test failure on change of default (in block_fetcher_test) now has a comment about how to upgrade the test. The format compatibility test does not need updating because we have not updated the default format_version. Reviewed By: ajkr, mrambacher Differential Revision: D33100915 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 8679e3e572fa580181a737fd6d113ed53c5422ee
2023-07-30 23:40:01 +00:00
return Status::OK();
}
std::string Footer::ToString() const {
std::string result;
result.reserve(1024);
result.append("metaindex handle: " + metaindex_handle_.ToString() +
" offset: " + std::to_string(metaindex_handle_.offset()) +
" size: " + std::to_string(metaindex_handle_.size()) + "\n ");
result.append("index handle: " + index_handle_.ToString() +
" offset: " + std::to_string(index_handle_.offset()) +
" size: " + std::to_string(index_handle_.size()) + "\n ");
result.append("table_magic_number: " + std::to_string(table_magic_number_) +
"\n ");
if (!IsLegacyFooterFormat(table_magic_number_)) {
result.append("format version: " + std::to_string(format_version_) + "\n");
}
return result;
}
Status ReadFooterFromFile(const IOOptions& opts, RandomAccessFileReader* file,
FileSystem& fs, FilePrefetchBuffer* prefetch_buffer,
uint64_t file_size, Footer* footer,
uint64_t enforce_table_magic_number) {
if (file_size < Footer::kMinEncodedLength) {
return Status::Corruption("file is too short (" +
std::to_string(file_size) +
" bytes) to be an "
"sstable: " +
file->file_name());
}
std::string footer_buf;
AlignedBuf internal_buf;
Slice footer_input;
uint64_t read_offset = (file_size > Footer::kMaxEncodedLength)
? file_size - Footer::kMaxEncodedLength
: 0;
Status s;
// TODO: Need to pass appropriate deadline to TryReadFromCache(). Right now,
// there is no readahead for point lookups, so TryReadFromCache will fail if
// the required data is not in the prefetch buffer. Once deadline is enabled
// for iterator, TryReadFromCache might do a readahead. Revisit to see if we
// need to pass a timeout at that point
Add rate limiter priority to ReadOptions (#9424) Summary: Users can set the priority for file reads associated with their operation by setting `ReadOptions::rate_limiter_priority` to something other than `Env::IO_TOTAL`. Rate limiting `VerifyChecksum()` and `VerifyFileChecksums()` is the motivation for this PR, so it also includes benchmarks and minor bug fixes to get that working. `RandomAccessFileReader::Read()` already had support for rate limiting compaction reads. I changed that rate limiting to be non-specific to compaction, but rather performed according to the passed in `Env::IOPriority`. Now the compaction read rate limiting is supported by setting `rate_limiter_priority = Env::IO_LOW` on its `ReadOptions`. There is no default value for the new `Env::IOPriority` parameter to `RandomAccessFileReader::Read()`. That means this PR goes through all callers (in some cases multiple layers up the call stack) to find a `ReadOptions` to provide the priority. There are TODOs for cases I believe it would be good to let user control the priority some day (e.g., file footer reads), and no TODO in cases I believe it doesn't matter (e.g., trace file reads). The API doc only lists the missing cases where a file read associated with a provided `ReadOptions` cannot be rate limited. For cases like file ingestion checksum calculation, there is no API to provide `ReadOptions` or `Env::IOPriority`, so I didn't count that as missing. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9424 Test Plan: - new unit tests - new benchmarks on ~50MB database with 1MB/s read rate limit and 100ms refill interval; verified with strace reads are chunked (at 0.1MB per chunk) and spaced roughly 100ms apart. - setup command: `./db_bench -benchmarks=fillrandom,compact -db=/tmp/testdb -target_file_size_base=1048576 -disable_auto_compactions=true -file_checksum=true` - benchmarks command: `strace -ttfe pread64 ./db_bench -benchmarks=verifychecksum,verifyfilechecksums -use_existing_db=true -db=/tmp/testdb -rate_limiter_bytes_per_sec=1048576 -rate_limit_bg_reads=1 -rate_limit_user_ops=true -file_checksum=true` - crash test using IO_USER priority on non-validation reads with https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/issues/9567 reverted: `python3 tools/db_crashtest.py blackbox --max_key=1000000 --write_buffer_size=524288 --target_file_size_base=524288 --level_compaction_dynamic_level_bytes=true --duration=3600 --rate_limit_bg_reads=true --rate_limit_user_ops=true --rate_limiter_bytes_per_sec=10485760 --interval=10` Reviewed By: hx235 Differential Revision: D33747386 Pulled By: ajkr fbshipit-source-id: a2d985e97912fba8c54763798e04f006ccc56e0c
2022-02-17 07:17:03 +00:00
// TODO: rate limit footer reads.
if (prefetch_buffer == nullptr ||
Group rocksdb.sst.read.micros stat by different user read IOActivity + misc (#11444) Summary: **Context/Summary:** - Similar to https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11288 but for user read such as `Get(), MultiGet(), DBIterator::XXX(), Verify(File)Checksum()`. - For this, I refactored some user-facing `MultiGet` calls in `TransactionBase` and various types of `DB` so that it does not call a user-facing `Get()` but `GetImpl()` for passing the `ReadOptions::io_activity` check (see PR conversation) - New user read stats breakdown are guarded by `kExceptDetailedTimers` since measurement shows they have 4-5% regression to the upstream/main. - Misc - More refactoring: with https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11288, we complete passing `ReadOptions/IOOptions` to FS level. So we can now replace the previously [added](https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9424) `rate_limiter_priority` parameter in `RandomAccessFileReader`'s `Read/MultiRead/Prefetch()` with `IOOptions::rate_limiter_priority` - Also, `ReadAsync()` call time is measured in `SST_READ_MICRO` now Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11444 Test Plan: - CI fake db crash/stress test - Microbenchmarking **Build** `make clean && ROCKSDB_NO_FBCODE=1 DEBUG_LEVEL=0 make -jN db_basic_bench` - google benchmark version: https://github.com/google/benchmark/commit/604f6fd3f4b34a84ec4eb4db81d842fa4db829cd - db_basic_bench_base: upstream - db_basic_bench_pr: db_basic_bench_base + this PR - asyncread_db_basic_bench_base: upstream + [db basic bench patch for IteratorNext](https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/compare/main...hx235:rocksdb:micro_bench_async_read) - asyncread_db_basic_bench_pr: asyncread_db_basic_bench_base + this PR **Test** Get ``` TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_basic_bench_{null_stat|base|pr} --benchmark_filter=DBGet/comp_style:0/max_data:134217728/per_key_size:256/enable_statistics:1/negative_query:0/enable_filter:0/mmap:1/threads:1 --benchmark_repetitions=1000 ``` Result ``` Coming soon ``` AsyncRead ``` TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./asyncread_db_basic_bench_{base|pr} --benchmark_filter=IteratorNext/comp_style:0/max_data:134217728/per_key_size:256/enable_statistics:1/async_io:1/include_detailed_timers:0 --benchmark_repetitions=1000 > syncread_db_basic_bench_{base|pr}.out ``` Result ``` Base: 1956,1956,1968,1977,1979,1986,1988,1988,1988,1990,1991,1991,1993,1993,1993,1993,1994,1996,1997,1997,1997,1998,1999,2001,2001,2002,2004,2007,2007,2008, PR (2.3% regression, due to measuring `SST_READ_MICRO` that wasn't measured before): 1993,2014,2016,2022,2024,2027,2027,2028,2028,2030,2031,2031,2032,2032,2038,2039,2042,2044,2044,2047,2047,2047,2048,2049,2050,2052,2052,2052,2053,2053, ``` Reviewed By: ajkr Differential Revision: D45918925 Pulled By: hx235 fbshipit-source-id: 58a54560d9ebeb3a59b6d807639692614dad058a
2023-08-09 00:26:50 +00:00
!prefetch_buffer->TryReadFromCache(opts, file, read_offset,
Footer::kMaxEncodedLength,
&footer_input, nullptr)) {
if (file->use_direct_io()) {
s = file->Read(opts, read_offset, Footer::kMaxEncodedLength,
Group rocksdb.sst.read.micros stat by different user read IOActivity + misc (#11444) Summary: **Context/Summary:** - Similar to https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11288 but for user read such as `Get(), MultiGet(), DBIterator::XXX(), Verify(File)Checksum()`. - For this, I refactored some user-facing `MultiGet` calls in `TransactionBase` and various types of `DB` so that it does not call a user-facing `Get()` but `GetImpl()` for passing the `ReadOptions::io_activity` check (see PR conversation) - New user read stats breakdown are guarded by `kExceptDetailedTimers` since measurement shows they have 4-5% regression to the upstream/main. - Misc - More refactoring: with https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11288, we complete passing `ReadOptions/IOOptions` to FS level. So we can now replace the previously [added](https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/9424) `rate_limiter_priority` parameter in `RandomAccessFileReader`'s `Read/MultiRead/Prefetch()` with `IOOptions::rate_limiter_priority` - Also, `ReadAsync()` call time is measured in `SST_READ_MICRO` now Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11444 Test Plan: - CI fake db crash/stress test - Microbenchmarking **Build** `make clean && ROCKSDB_NO_FBCODE=1 DEBUG_LEVEL=0 make -jN db_basic_bench` - google benchmark version: https://github.com/google/benchmark/commit/604f6fd3f4b34a84ec4eb4db81d842fa4db829cd - db_basic_bench_base: upstream - db_basic_bench_pr: db_basic_bench_base + this PR - asyncread_db_basic_bench_base: upstream + [db basic bench patch for IteratorNext](https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/compare/main...hx235:rocksdb:micro_bench_async_read) - asyncread_db_basic_bench_pr: asyncread_db_basic_bench_base + this PR **Test** Get ``` TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_basic_bench_{null_stat|base|pr} --benchmark_filter=DBGet/comp_style:0/max_data:134217728/per_key_size:256/enable_statistics:1/negative_query:0/enable_filter:0/mmap:1/threads:1 --benchmark_repetitions=1000 ``` Result ``` Coming soon ``` AsyncRead ``` TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./asyncread_db_basic_bench_{base|pr} --benchmark_filter=IteratorNext/comp_style:0/max_data:134217728/per_key_size:256/enable_statistics:1/async_io:1/include_detailed_timers:0 --benchmark_repetitions=1000 > syncread_db_basic_bench_{base|pr}.out ``` Result ``` Base: 1956,1956,1968,1977,1979,1986,1988,1988,1988,1990,1991,1991,1993,1993,1993,1993,1994,1996,1997,1997,1997,1998,1999,2001,2001,2002,2004,2007,2007,2008, PR (2.3% regression, due to measuring `SST_READ_MICRO` that wasn't measured before): 1993,2014,2016,2022,2024,2027,2027,2028,2028,2030,2031,2031,2032,2032,2038,2039,2042,2044,2044,2047,2047,2047,2048,2049,2050,2052,2052,2052,2053,2053, ``` Reviewed By: ajkr Differential Revision: D45918925 Pulled By: hx235 fbshipit-source-id: 58a54560d9ebeb3a59b6d807639692614dad058a
2023-08-09 00:26:50 +00:00
&footer_input, nullptr, &internal_buf);
} else {
footer_buf.reserve(Footer::kMaxEncodedLength);
s = file->Read(opts, read_offset, Footer::kMaxEncodedLength,
&footer_input, footer_buf.data(), nullptr);
}
if (!s.ok()) {
return s;
}
}
// Check that we actually read the whole footer from the file. It may be
// that size isn't correct.
if (footer_input.size() < Footer::kMinEncodedLength) {
uint64_t size_on_disk = 0;
if (fs.GetFileSize(file->file_name(), IOOptions(), &size_on_disk, nullptr)
.ok()) {
// Similar to CheckConsistency message, but not completely sure the
// expected size always came from manifest.
return Status::Corruption("Sst file size mismatch: " + file->file_name() +
". Expected " + std::to_string(file_size) +
", actual size " +
std::to_string(size_on_disk) + "\n");
} else {
return Status::Corruption(
"Missing SST footer data in file " + file->file_name() +
" File too short? Expected size: " + std::to_string(file_size));
}
}
s = footer->DecodeFrom(footer_input, read_offset, enforce_table_magic_number);
if (!s.ok()) {
s = Status::CopyAppendMessage(s, " in ", file->file_name());
return s;
}
return Status::OK();
}
namespace {
// Custom handling for the last byte of a block, to avoid invoking streaming
// API to get an effective block checksum. This function is its own inverse
// because it uses xor.
inline uint32_t ModifyChecksumForLastByte(uint32_t checksum, char last_byte) {
// This strategy bears some resemblance to extending a CRC checksum by one
// more byte, except we don't need to re-mix the input checksum as long as
// we do this step only once (per checksum).
const uint32_t kRandomPrime = 0x6b9083d9;
return checksum ^ lossless_cast<uint8_t>(last_byte) * kRandomPrime;
}
} // namespace
uint32_t ComputeBuiltinChecksum(ChecksumType type, const char* data,
size_t data_size) {
switch (type) {
case kCRC32c:
return crc32c::Mask(crc32c::Value(data, data_size));
case kxxHash:
return XXH32(data, data_size, /*seed*/ 0);
case kxxHash64:
return Lower32of64(XXH64(data, data_size, /*seed*/ 0));
case kXXH3: {
if (data_size == 0) {
// Special case because of special handling for last byte, not
// present in this case. Can be any value different from other
// small input size checksums.
return 0;
} else {
// See corresponding code in ComputeBuiltinChecksumWithLastByte
uint32_t v = Lower32of64(XXH3_64bits(data, data_size - 1));
return ModifyChecksumForLastByte(v, data[data_size - 1]);
}
}
default: // including kNoChecksum
return 0;
}
}
uint32_t ComputeBuiltinChecksumWithLastByte(ChecksumType type, const char* data,
size_t data_size, char last_byte) {
switch (type) {
case kCRC32c: {
uint32_t crc = crc32c::Value(data, data_size);
// Extend to cover last byte (compression type)
crc = crc32c::Extend(crc, &last_byte, 1);
return crc32c::Mask(crc);
}
case kxxHash: {
XXH32_state_t* const state = XXH32_createState();
XXH32_reset(state, 0);
XXH32_update(state, data, data_size);
// Extend to cover last byte (compression type)
XXH32_update(state, &last_byte, 1);
uint32_t v = XXH32_digest(state);
XXH32_freeState(state);
return v;
}
case kxxHash64: {
XXH64_state_t* const state = XXH64_createState();
XXH64_reset(state, 0);
XXH64_update(state, data, data_size);
// Extend to cover last byte (compression type)
XXH64_update(state, &last_byte, 1);
uint32_t v = Lower32of64(XXH64_digest(state));
XXH64_freeState(state);
return v;
}
case kXXH3: {
// XXH3 is a complicated hash function that is extremely fast on
// contiguous input, but that makes its streaming support rather
// complex. It is worth custom handling of the last byte (`type`)
// in order to avoid allocating a large state object and bringing
// that code complexity into CPU working set.
uint32_t v = Lower32of64(XXH3_64bits(data, data_size));
return ModifyChecksumForLastByte(v, last_byte);
}
default: // including kNoChecksum
return 0;
}
}
Refactor to avoid confusing "raw block" (#10408) Summary: We have a lot of confusing code because of mixed, sometimes completely opposite uses of of the term "raw block" or "raw contents", sometimes within the same source file. For example, in `BlockBasedTableBuilder`, `raw_block_contents` and `raw_size` generally referred to uncompressed block contents and size, while `WriteRawBlock` referred to writing a block that is already compressed if it is going to be. Meanwhile, in `BlockBasedTable`, `raw_block_contents` either referred to a (maybe compressed) block with trailer, or a maybe compressed block maybe without trailer. (Note: left as follow-up work to use C++ typing to better sort out the various kinds of BlockContents.) This change primarily tries to apply some consistent terminology around the kinds of block representations, avoiding the unclear "raw". (Any meaning of "raw" assumes some bias toward the storage layer or toward the logical data layer.) Preferred terminology: * **Serialized block** - bytes that go into storage. For block-based table (usually the case) this includes the block trailer. WART: block `size` may or may not include the trailer; need to be clear about whether it does or not. * **Maybe compressed block** - like a serialized block, but without the trailer (or no promise of including a trailer). Must be accompanied by a CompressionType. * **Uncompressed block** - "payload" bytes that are either stored with no compression, used as input to compression function, or result of decompression function. * **Parsed block** - an in-memory form of a block in block cache, as it is used by the table reader. Different C++ types are used depending on the block type (see block_like_traits.h). Other refactorings: * Misc corrections/improvements of internal API comments * Remove a few misleading / unhelpful / redundant comments. * Use move semantics in some places to simplify contracts * Use better parameter names to indicate which parameters are used for outputs * Remove some extraneous `extern` * Various clean-ups to `CacheDumperImpl` (mostly unnecessary code) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/10408 Test Plan: existing tests Reviewed By: akankshamahajan15 Differential Revision: D38172617 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: ccb99299f324ac5ca46996d34c5089621a4f260c
2022-09-22 18:25:32 +00:00
Status UncompressBlockData(const UncompressionInfo& uncompression_info,
const char* data, size_t size,
BlockContents* out_contents, uint32_t format_version,
const ImmutableOptions& ioptions,
MemoryAllocator* allocator) {
Status ret = Status::OK();
assert(uncompression_info.type() != kNoCompression &&
"Invalid compression type");
StopWatchNano timer(ioptions.clock,
ShouldReportDetailedTime(ioptions.env, ioptions.stats));
size_t uncompressed_size = 0;
Add `CompressionOptions::checksum` for enabling ZSTD checksum (#11666) Summary: Optionally enable zstd checksum flag (https://github.com/facebook/zstd/blob/d857369028d997c92ff1f1861a4d7f679a125464/lib/zstd.h#L428) to detect corruption during decompression. Main changes are in compression.h: * User can set CompressionOptions::checksum to true to enable this feature. * We enable this feature in ZSTD by setting the checksum flag in ZSTD compression context: `ZSTD_CCtx`. * Uses `ZSTD_compress2()` to do compression since it supports frame parameter like the checksum flag. Compression level is also set in compression context as a flag. * Error handling during decompression to propagate error message from ZSTD. * Updated microbench to test read performance impact. About compatibility, the current compression decoders should continue to work with the data created by the new compression API `ZSTD_compress2()`: https://github.com/facebook/zstd/issues/3711. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11666 Test Plan: * Existing unit tests for zstd compression * Add unit test `DBTest2.ZSTDChecksum` to test the corruption case * Manually tested that compression levels, parallel compression, dictionary compression, index compression all work with the new ZSTD_compress2() API. * Manually tested with `sst_dump --command=recompress` that different compression levels and dictionary compression settings all work. * Manually tested compiling with older versions of ZSTD: v1.3.8, v1.1.0, v0.6.2. * Perf impact: from public benchmark data: http://fastcompression.blogspot.com/2019/03/presenting-xxh3.html for checksum and https://github.com/facebook/zstd#benchmarks, if decompression is 1700MB/s and checksum computation is 70000MB/s, checksum computation is an additional ~2.4% time for decompression. Compression is slower and checksumming should be less noticeable. * Microbench: ``` TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./branch_db_basic_bench --benchmark_filter=DBGet/comp_style:0/max_data:1048576/per_key_size:256/enable_statistics:0/negative_query:0/enable_filter:0/mmap:0/compression_type:7/compression_checksum:1/no_blockcache:1/iterations:10000/threads:1 --benchmark_repetitions=100 Min out of 100 runs: Main: 10390 10436 10456 10484 10499 10535 10544 10545 10565 10568 After this PR, checksum=false 10285 10397 10503 10508 10515 10557 10562 10635 10640 10660 After this PR, checksum=true 10827 10876 10925 10949 10971 11052 11061 11063 11100 11109 ``` * db_bench: ``` Write perf TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/ ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=fillseq[-X10] --compression_type=zstd --num=10000000 --compression_checksum=.. [FillSeq checksum=0] fillseq [AVG 10 runs] : 281635 (± 31711) ops/sec; 31.2 (± 3.5) MB/sec fillseq [MEDIAN 10 runs] : 294027 ops/sec; 32.5 MB/sec [FillSeq checksum=1] fillseq [AVG 10 runs] : 286961 (± 34700) ops/sec; 31.7 (± 3.8) MB/sec fillseq [MEDIAN 10 runs] : 283278 ops/sec; 31.3 MB/sec Read perf TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=readrandom[-X20] --num=100000000 --reads=1000000 --use_existing_db=true --readonly=1 [Readrandom checksum=1] readrandom [AVG 20 runs] : 360928 (± 3579) ops/sec; 4.0 (± 0.0) MB/sec readrandom [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 362468 ops/sec; 4.0 MB/sec [Readrandom checksum=0] readrandom [AVG 20 runs] : 380365 (± 2384) ops/sec; 4.2 (± 0.0) MB/sec readrandom [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 379800 ops/sec; 4.2 MB/sec Compression TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=compress[-X20] --compression_type=zstd --num=100000000 --compression_checksum=1 checksum=1 compress [AVG 20 runs] : 54074 (± 634) ops/sec; 211.2 (± 2.5) MB/sec compress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 54396 ops/sec; 212.5 MB/sec checksum=0 compress [AVG 20 runs] : 54598 (± 393) ops/sec; 213.3 (± 1.5) MB/sec compress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 54592 ops/sec; 213.3 MB/sec Decompression: TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=uncompress[-X20] --compression_type=zstd --compression_checksum=1 checksum = 0 uncompress [AVG 20 runs] : 167499 (± 962) ops/sec; 654.3 (± 3.8) MB/sec uncompress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 167210 ops/sec; 653.2 MB/sec checksum = 1 uncompress [AVG 20 runs] : 167980 (± 924) ops/sec; 656.2 (± 3.6) MB/sec uncompress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 168465 ops/sec; 658.1 MB/sec ``` Reviewed By: ajkr Differential Revision: D48019378 Pulled By: cbi42 fbshipit-source-id: 674120c6e1853c2ced1436ac8138559d0204feba
2023-08-18 22:01:59 +00:00
const char* error_msg = nullptr;
CacheAllocationPtr ubuf = UncompressData(
uncompression_info, data, size, &uncompressed_size,
GetCompressFormatForVersion(format_version), allocator, &error_msg);
if (!ubuf) {
if (!CompressionTypeSupported(uncompression_info.type())) {
Add `CompressionOptions::checksum` for enabling ZSTD checksum (#11666) Summary: Optionally enable zstd checksum flag (https://github.com/facebook/zstd/blob/d857369028d997c92ff1f1861a4d7f679a125464/lib/zstd.h#L428) to detect corruption during decompression. Main changes are in compression.h: * User can set CompressionOptions::checksum to true to enable this feature. * We enable this feature in ZSTD by setting the checksum flag in ZSTD compression context: `ZSTD_CCtx`. * Uses `ZSTD_compress2()` to do compression since it supports frame parameter like the checksum flag. Compression level is also set in compression context as a flag. * Error handling during decompression to propagate error message from ZSTD. * Updated microbench to test read performance impact. About compatibility, the current compression decoders should continue to work with the data created by the new compression API `ZSTD_compress2()`: https://github.com/facebook/zstd/issues/3711. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11666 Test Plan: * Existing unit tests for zstd compression * Add unit test `DBTest2.ZSTDChecksum` to test the corruption case * Manually tested that compression levels, parallel compression, dictionary compression, index compression all work with the new ZSTD_compress2() API. * Manually tested with `sst_dump --command=recompress` that different compression levels and dictionary compression settings all work. * Manually tested compiling with older versions of ZSTD: v1.3.8, v1.1.0, v0.6.2. * Perf impact: from public benchmark data: http://fastcompression.blogspot.com/2019/03/presenting-xxh3.html for checksum and https://github.com/facebook/zstd#benchmarks, if decompression is 1700MB/s and checksum computation is 70000MB/s, checksum computation is an additional ~2.4% time for decompression. Compression is slower and checksumming should be less noticeable. * Microbench: ``` TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./branch_db_basic_bench --benchmark_filter=DBGet/comp_style:0/max_data:1048576/per_key_size:256/enable_statistics:0/negative_query:0/enable_filter:0/mmap:0/compression_type:7/compression_checksum:1/no_blockcache:1/iterations:10000/threads:1 --benchmark_repetitions=100 Min out of 100 runs: Main: 10390 10436 10456 10484 10499 10535 10544 10545 10565 10568 After this PR, checksum=false 10285 10397 10503 10508 10515 10557 10562 10635 10640 10660 After this PR, checksum=true 10827 10876 10925 10949 10971 11052 11061 11063 11100 11109 ``` * db_bench: ``` Write perf TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/ ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=fillseq[-X10] --compression_type=zstd --num=10000000 --compression_checksum=.. [FillSeq checksum=0] fillseq [AVG 10 runs] : 281635 (± 31711) ops/sec; 31.2 (± 3.5) MB/sec fillseq [MEDIAN 10 runs] : 294027 ops/sec; 32.5 MB/sec [FillSeq checksum=1] fillseq [AVG 10 runs] : 286961 (± 34700) ops/sec; 31.7 (± 3.8) MB/sec fillseq [MEDIAN 10 runs] : 283278 ops/sec; 31.3 MB/sec Read perf TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=readrandom[-X20] --num=100000000 --reads=1000000 --use_existing_db=true --readonly=1 [Readrandom checksum=1] readrandom [AVG 20 runs] : 360928 (± 3579) ops/sec; 4.0 (± 0.0) MB/sec readrandom [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 362468 ops/sec; 4.0 MB/sec [Readrandom checksum=0] readrandom [AVG 20 runs] : 380365 (± 2384) ops/sec; 4.2 (± 0.0) MB/sec readrandom [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 379800 ops/sec; 4.2 MB/sec Compression TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=compress[-X20] --compression_type=zstd --num=100000000 --compression_checksum=1 checksum=1 compress [AVG 20 runs] : 54074 (± 634) ops/sec; 211.2 (± 2.5) MB/sec compress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 54396 ops/sec; 212.5 MB/sec checksum=0 compress [AVG 20 runs] : 54598 (± 393) ops/sec; 213.3 (± 1.5) MB/sec compress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 54592 ops/sec; 213.3 MB/sec Decompression: TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=uncompress[-X20] --compression_type=zstd --compression_checksum=1 checksum = 0 uncompress [AVG 20 runs] : 167499 (± 962) ops/sec; 654.3 (± 3.8) MB/sec uncompress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 167210 ops/sec; 653.2 MB/sec checksum = 1 uncompress [AVG 20 runs] : 167980 (± 924) ops/sec; 656.2 (± 3.6) MB/sec uncompress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 168465 ops/sec; 658.1 MB/sec ``` Reviewed By: ajkr Differential Revision: D48019378 Pulled By: cbi42 fbshipit-source-id: 674120c6e1853c2ced1436ac8138559d0204feba
2023-08-18 22:01:59 +00:00
ret = Status::NotSupported(
"Unsupported compression method for this build",
CompressionTypeToString(uncompression_info.type()));
} else {
Add `CompressionOptions::checksum` for enabling ZSTD checksum (#11666) Summary: Optionally enable zstd checksum flag (https://github.com/facebook/zstd/blob/d857369028d997c92ff1f1861a4d7f679a125464/lib/zstd.h#L428) to detect corruption during decompression. Main changes are in compression.h: * User can set CompressionOptions::checksum to true to enable this feature. * We enable this feature in ZSTD by setting the checksum flag in ZSTD compression context: `ZSTD_CCtx`. * Uses `ZSTD_compress2()` to do compression since it supports frame parameter like the checksum flag. Compression level is also set in compression context as a flag. * Error handling during decompression to propagate error message from ZSTD. * Updated microbench to test read performance impact. About compatibility, the current compression decoders should continue to work with the data created by the new compression API `ZSTD_compress2()`: https://github.com/facebook/zstd/issues/3711. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11666 Test Plan: * Existing unit tests for zstd compression * Add unit test `DBTest2.ZSTDChecksum` to test the corruption case * Manually tested that compression levels, parallel compression, dictionary compression, index compression all work with the new ZSTD_compress2() API. * Manually tested with `sst_dump --command=recompress` that different compression levels and dictionary compression settings all work. * Manually tested compiling with older versions of ZSTD: v1.3.8, v1.1.0, v0.6.2. * Perf impact: from public benchmark data: http://fastcompression.blogspot.com/2019/03/presenting-xxh3.html for checksum and https://github.com/facebook/zstd#benchmarks, if decompression is 1700MB/s and checksum computation is 70000MB/s, checksum computation is an additional ~2.4% time for decompression. Compression is slower and checksumming should be less noticeable. * Microbench: ``` TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./branch_db_basic_bench --benchmark_filter=DBGet/comp_style:0/max_data:1048576/per_key_size:256/enable_statistics:0/negative_query:0/enable_filter:0/mmap:0/compression_type:7/compression_checksum:1/no_blockcache:1/iterations:10000/threads:1 --benchmark_repetitions=100 Min out of 100 runs: Main: 10390 10436 10456 10484 10499 10535 10544 10545 10565 10568 After this PR, checksum=false 10285 10397 10503 10508 10515 10557 10562 10635 10640 10660 After this PR, checksum=true 10827 10876 10925 10949 10971 11052 11061 11063 11100 11109 ``` * db_bench: ``` Write perf TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/ ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=fillseq[-X10] --compression_type=zstd --num=10000000 --compression_checksum=.. [FillSeq checksum=0] fillseq [AVG 10 runs] : 281635 (± 31711) ops/sec; 31.2 (± 3.5) MB/sec fillseq [MEDIAN 10 runs] : 294027 ops/sec; 32.5 MB/sec [FillSeq checksum=1] fillseq [AVG 10 runs] : 286961 (± 34700) ops/sec; 31.7 (± 3.8) MB/sec fillseq [MEDIAN 10 runs] : 283278 ops/sec; 31.3 MB/sec Read perf TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=readrandom[-X20] --num=100000000 --reads=1000000 --use_existing_db=true --readonly=1 [Readrandom checksum=1] readrandom [AVG 20 runs] : 360928 (± 3579) ops/sec; 4.0 (± 0.0) MB/sec readrandom [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 362468 ops/sec; 4.0 MB/sec [Readrandom checksum=0] readrandom [AVG 20 runs] : 380365 (± 2384) ops/sec; 4.2 (± 0.0) MB/sec readrandom [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 379800 ops/sec; 4.2 MB/sec Compression TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=compress[-X20] --compression_type=zstd --num=100000000 --compression_checksum=1 checksum=1 compress [AVG 20 runs] : 54074 (± 634) ops/sec; 211.2 (± 2.5) MB/sec compress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 54396 ops/sec; 212.5 MB/sec checksum=0 compress [AVG 20 runs] : 54598 (± 393) ops/sec; 213.3 (± 1.5) MB/sec compress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 54592 ops/sec; 213.3 MB/sec Decompression: TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=uncompress[-X20] --compression_type=zstd --compression_checksum=1 checksum = 0 uncompress [AVG 20 runs] : 167499 (± 962) ops/sec; 654.3 (± 3.8) MB/sec uncompress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 167210 ops/sec; 653.2 MB/sec checksum = 1 uncompress [AVG 20 runs] : 167980 (± 924) ops/sec; 656.2 (± 3.6) MB/sec uncompress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 168465 ops/sec; 658.1 MB/sec ``` Reviewed By: ajkr Differential Revision: D48019378 Pulled By: cbi42 fbshipit-source-id: 674120c6e1853c2ced1436ac8138559d0204feba
2023-08-18 22:01:59 +00:00
std::ostringstream oss;
oss << "Corrupted compressed block contents";
if (error_msg) {
oss << ": " << error_msg;
}
ret = Status::Corruption(
oss.str(), CompressionTypeToString(uncompression_info.type()));
}
Add `CompressionOptions::checksum` for enabling ZSTD checksum (#11666) Summary: Optionally enable zstd checksum flag (https://github.com/facebook/zstd/blob/d857369028d997c92ff1f1861a4d7f679a125464/lib/zstd.h#L428) to detect corruption during decompression. Main changes are in compression.h: * User can set CompressionOptions::checksum to true to enable this feature. * We enable this feature in ZSTD by setting the checksum flag in ZSTD compression context: `ZSTD_CCtx`. * Uses `ZSTD_compress2()` to do compression since it supports frame parameter like the checksum flag. Compression level is also set in compression context as a flag. * Error handling during decompression to propagate error message from ZSTD. * Updated microbench to test read performance impact. About compatibility, the current compression decoders should continue to work with the data created by the new compression API `ZSTD_compress2()`: https://github.com/facebook/zstd/issues/3711. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11666 Test Plan: * Existing unit tests for zstd compression * Add unit test `DBTest2.ZSTDChecksum` to test the corruption case * Manually tested that compression levels, parallel compression, dictionary compression, index compression all work with the new ZSTD_compress2() API. * Manually tested with `sst_dump --command=recompress` that different compression levels and dictionary compression settings all work. * Manually tested compiling with older versions of ZSTD: v1.3.8, v1.1.0, v0.6.2. * Perf impact: from public benchmark data: http://fastcompression.blogspot.com/2019/03/presenting-xxh3.html for checksum and https://github.com/facebook/zstd#benchmarks, if decompression is 1700MB/s and checksum computation is 70000MB/s, checksum computation is an additional ~2.4% time for decompression. Compression is slower and checksumming should be less noticeable. * Microbench: ``` TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./branch_db_basic_bench --benchmark_filter=DBGet/comp_style:0/max_data:1048576/per_key_size:256/enable_statistics:0/negative_query:0/enable_filter:0/mmap:0/compression_type:7/compression_checksum:1/no_blockcache:1/iterations:10000/threads:1 --benchmark_repetitions=100 Min out of 100 runs: Main: 10390 10436 10456 10484 10499 10535 10544 10545 10565 10568 After this PR, checksum=false 10285 10397 10503 10508 10515 10557 10562 10635 10640 10660 After this PR, checksum=true 10827 10876 10925 10949 10971 11052 11061 11063 11100 11109 ``` * db_bench: ``` Write perf TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm/ ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=fillseq[-X10] --compression_type=zstd --num=10000000 --compression_checksum=.. [FillSeq checksum=0] fillseq [AVG 10 runs] : 281635 (± 31711) ops/sec; 31.2 (± 3.5) MB/sec fillseq [MEDIAN 10 runs] : 294027 ops/sec; 32.5 MB/sec [FillSeq checksum=1] fillseq [AVG 10 runs] : 286961 (± 34700) ops/sec; 31.7 (± 3.8) MB/sec fillseq [MEDIAN 10 runs] : 283278 ops/sec; 31.3 MB/sec Read perf TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=readrandom[-X20] --num=100000000 --reads=1000000 --use_existing_db=true --readonly=1 [Readrandom checksum=1] readrandom [AVG 20 runs] : 360928 (± 3579) ops/sec; 4.0 (± 0.0) MB/sec readrandom [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 362468 ops/sec; 4.0 MB/sec [Readrandom checksum=0] readrandom [AVG 20 runs] : 380365 (± 2384) ops/sec; 4.2 (± 0.0) MB/sec readrandom [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 379800 ops/sec; 4.2 MB/sec Compression TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=compress[-X20] --compression_type=zstd --num=100000000 --compression_checksum=1 checksum=1 compress [AVG 20 runs] : 54074 (± 634) ops/sec; 211.2 (± 2.5) MB/sec compress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 54396 ops/sec; 212.5 MB/sec checksum=0 compress [AVG 20 runs] : 54598 (± 393) ops/sec; 213.3 (± 1.5) MB/sec compress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 54592 ops/sec; 213.3 MB/sec Decompression: TEST_TMPDIR=/dev/shm ./db_bench_ichecksum --benchmarks=uncompress[-X20] --compression_type=zstd --compression_checksum=1 checksum = 0 uncompress [AVG 20 runs] : 167499 (± 962) ops/sec; 654.3 (± 3.8) MB/sec uncompress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 167210 ops/sec; 653.2 MB/sec checksum = 1 uncompress [AVG 20 runs] : 167980 (± 924) ops/sec; 656.2 (± 3.6) MB/sec uncompress [MEDIAN 20 runs] : 168465 ops/sec; 658.1 MB/sec ``` Reviewed By: ajkr Differential Revision: D48019378 Pulled By: cbi42 fbshipit-source-id: 674120c6e1853c2ced1436ac8138559d0204feba
2023-08-18 22:01:59 +00:00
return ret;
}
Refactor to avoid confusing "raw block" (#10408) Summary: We have a lot of confusing code because of mixed, sometimes completely opposite uses of of the term "raw block" or "raw contents", sometimes within the same source file. For example, in `BlockBasedTableBuilder`, `raw_block_contents` and `raw_size` generally referred to uncompressed block contents and size, while `WriteRawBlock` referred to writing a block that is already compressed if it is going to be. Meanwhile, in `BlockBasedTable`, `raw_block_contents` either referred to a (maybe compressed) block with trailer, or a maybe compressed block maybe without trailer. (Note: left as follow-up work to use C++ typing to better sort out the various kinds of BlockContents.) This change primarily tries to apply some consistent terminology around the kinds of block representations, avoiding the unclear "raw". (Any meaning of "raw" assumes some bias toward the storage layer or toward the logical data layer.) Preferred terminology: * **Serialized block** - bytes that go into storage. For block-based table (usually the case) this includes the block trailer. WART: block `size` may or may not include the trailer; need to be clear about whether it does or not. * **Maybe compressed block** - like a serialized block, but without the trailer (or no promise of including a trailer). Must be accompanied by a CompressionType. * **Uncompressed block** - "payload" bytes that are either stored with no compression, used as input to compression function, or result of decompression function. * **Parsed block** - an in-memory form of a block in block cache, as it is used by the table reader. Different C++ types are used depending on the block type (see block_like_traits.h). Other refactorings: * Misc corrections/improvements of internal API comments * Remove a few misleading / unhelpful / redundant comments. * Use move semantics in some places to simplify contracts * Use better parameter names to indicate which parameters are used for outputs * Remove some extraneous `extern` * Various clean-ups to `CacheDumperImpl` (mostly unnecessary code) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/10408 Test Plan: existing tests Reviewed By: akankshamahajan15 Differential Revision: D38172617 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: ccb99299f324ac5ca46996d34c5089621a4f260c
2022-09-22 18:25:32 +00:00
*out_contents = BlockContents(std::move(ubuf), uncompressed_size);
if (ShouldReportDetailedTime(ioptions.env, ioptions.stats)) {
RecordTimeToHistogram(ioptions.stats, DECOMPRESSION_TIMES_NANOS,
timer.ElapsedNanos());
}
Changes and enhancements to compression stats, thresholds (#11388) Summary: ## Option API updates * Add new CompressionOptions::max_compressed_bytes_per_kb, which corresponds to 1024.0 / min allowable compression ratio. This avoids the hard-coded minimum ratio of 8/7. * Remove unnecessary constructor for CompressionOptions. * Document undocumented CompressionOptions. Use idiom for default values shown clearly in one place (not precariously repeated). ## Stat API updates * Deprecate the BYTES_COMPRESSED, BYTES_DECOMPRESSED histograms. Histograms incur substantial extra space & time costs compared to tickers, and the distribution of uncompressed data block sizes tends to be uninteresting. If we're interested in that distribution, I don't see why it should be limited to blocks stored as compressed. * Deprecate the NUMBER_BLOCK_NOT_COMPRESSED ticker, because the name is very confusing. * New or existing tickers relevant to compression: * BYTES_COMPRESSED_FROM * BYTES_COMPRESSED_TO * BYTES_COMPRESSION_BYPASSED * BYTES_COMPRESSION_REJECTED * COMPACT_WRITE_BYTES + FLUSH_WRITE_BYTES (both existing) * NUMBER_BLOCK_COMPRESSED (existing) * NUMBER_BLOCK_COMPRESSION_BYPASSED * NUMBER_BLOCK_COMPRESSION_REJECTED * BYTES_DECOMPRESSED_FROM * BYTES_DECOMPRESSED_TO We can compute a number of things with these stats: * "Successful" compression ratio: BYTES_COMPRESSED_FROM / BYTES_COMPRESSED_TO * Compression ratio of data on which compression was attempted: (BYTES_COMPRESSED_FROM + BYTES_COMPRESSION_REJECTED) / (BYTES_COMPRESSED_TO + BYTES_COMPRESSION_REJECTED) * Compression ratio of data that could be eligible for compression: (BYTES_COMPRESSED_FROM + X) / (BYTES_COMPRESSED_TO + X) where X = BYTES_COMPRESSION_REJECTED + NUMBER_BLOCK_COMPRESSION_REJECTED * Overall SST compression ratio (compression disabled vs. actual): (Y - BYTES_COMPRESSED_TO + BYTES_COMPRESSED_FROM) / Y where Y = COMPACT_WRITE_BYTES + FLUSH_WRITE_BYTES Keeping _REJECTED separate from _BYPASSED helps us to understand "wasted" CPU time in compression. ## BlockBasedTableBuilder Various small refactorings, optimizations, and name clean-ups. Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/11388 Test Plan: unit tests added * `options_settable_test.cc`: use non-deprecated idiom for configuring CompressionOptions from string. The old idiom is tested elsewhere and does not need to be updated to support the new field. Reviewed By: ajkr Differential Revision: D45128202 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: 5a652bf5c022b7ec340cf79018cccf0686962803
2023-04-22 04:57:40 +00:00
RecordTick(ioptions.stats, BYTES_DECOMPRESSED_FROM, size);
RecordTick(ioptions.stats, BYTES_DECOMPRESSED_TO, out_contents->data.size());
RecordTick(ioptions.stats, NUMBER_BLOCK_DECOMPRESSED);
Refactor to avoid confusing "raw block" (#10408) Summary: We have a lot of confusing code because of mixed, sometimes completely opposite uses of of the term "raw block" or "raw contents", sometimes within the same source file. For example, in `BlockBasedTableBuilder`, `raw_block_contents` and `raw_size` generally referred to uncompressed block contents and size, while `WriteRawBlock` referred to writing a block that is already compressed if it is going to be. Meanwhile, in `BlockBasedTable`, `raw_block_contents` either referred to a (maybe compressed) block with trailer, or a maybe compressed block maybe without trailer. (Note: left as follow-up work to use C++ typing to better sort out the various kinds of BlockContents.) This change primarily tries to apply some consistent terminology around the kinds of block representations, avoiding the unclear "raw". (Any meaning of "raw" assumes some bias toward the storage layer or toward the logical data layer.) Preferred terminology: * **Serialized block** - bytes that go into storage. For block-based table (usually the case) this includes the block trailer. WART: block `size` may or may not include the trailer; need to be clear about whether it does or not. * **Maybe compressed block** - like a serialized block, but without the trailer (or no promise of including a trailer). Must be accompanied by a CompressionType. * **Uncompressed block** - "payload" bytes that are either stored with no compression, used as input to compression function, or result of decompression function. * **Parsed block** - an in-memory form of a block in block cache, as it is used by the table reader. Different C++ types are used depending on the block type (see block_like_traits.h). Other refactorings: * Misc corrections/improvements of internal API comments * Remove a few misleading / unhelpful / redundant comments. * Use move semantics in some places to simplify contracts * Use better parameter names to indicate which parameters are used for outputs * Remove some extraneous `extern` * Various clean-ups to `CacheDumperImpl` (mostly unnecessary code) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/10408 Test Plan: existing tests Reviewed By: akankshamahajan15 Differential Revision: D38172617 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: ccb99299f324ac5ca46996d34c5089621a4f260c
2022-09-22 18:25:32 +00:00
TEST_SYNC_POINT_CALLBACK("UncompressBlockData:TamperWithReturnValue",
static_cast<void*>(&ret));
TEST_SYNC_POINT_CALLBACK(
Refactor to avoid confusing "raw block" (#10408) Summary: We have a lot of confusing code because of mixed, sometimes completely opposite uses of of the term "raw block" or "raw contents", sometimes within the same source file. For example, in `BlockBasedTableBuilder`, `raw_block_contents` and `raw_size` generally referred to uncompressed block contents and size, while `WriteRawBlock` referred to writing a block that is already compressed if it is going to be. Meanwhile, in `BlockBasedTable`, `raw_block_contents` either referred to a (maybe compressed) block with trailer, or a maybe compressed block maybe without trailer. (Note: left as follow-up work to use C++ typing to better sort out the various kinds of BlockContents.) This change primarily tries to apply some consistent terminology around the kinds of block representations, avoiding the unclear "raw". (Any meaning of "raw" assumes some bias toward the storage layer or toward the logical data layer.) Preferred terminology: * **Serialized block** - bytes that go into storage. For block-based table (usually the case) this includes the block trailer. WART: block `size` may or may not include the trailer; need to be clear about whether it does or not. * **Maybe compressed block** - like a serialized block, but without the trailer (or no promise of including a trailer). Must be accompanied by a CompressionType. * **Uncompressed block** - "payload" bytes that are either stored with no compression, used as input to compression function, or result of decompression function. * **Parsed block** - an in-memory form of a block in block cache, as it is used by the table reader. Different C++ types are used depending on the block type (see block_like_traits.h). Other refactorings: * Misc corrections/improvements of internal API comments * Remove a few misleading / unhelpful / redundant comments. * Use move semantics in some places to simplify contracts * Use better parameter names to indicate which parameters are used for outputs * Remove some extraneous `extern` * Various clean-ups to `CacheDumperImpl` (mostly unnecessary code) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/10408 Test Plan: existing tests Reviewed By: akankshamahajan15 Differential Revision: D38172617 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: ccb99299f324ac5ca46996d34c5089621a4f260c
2022-09-22 18:25:32 +00:00
"UncompressBlockData:"
"TamperWithDecompressionOutput",
Refactor to avoid confusing "raw block" (#10408) Summary: We have a lot of confusing code because of mixed, sometimes completely opposite uses of of the term "raw block" or "raw contents", sometimes within the same source file. For example, in `BlockBasedTableBuilder`, `raw_block_contents` and `raw_size` generally referred to uncompressed block contents and size, while `WriteRawBlock` referred to writing a block that is already compressed if it is going to be. Meanwhile, in `BlockBasedTable`, `raw_block_contents` either referred to a (maybe compressed) block with trailer, or a maybe compressed block maybe without trailer. (Note: left as follow-up work to use C++ typing to better sort out the various kinds of BlockContents.) This change primarily tries to apply some consistent terminology around the kinds of block representations, avoiding the unclear "raw". (Any meaning of "raw" assumes some bias toward the storage layer or toward the logical data layer.) Preferred terminology: * **Serialized block** - bytes that go into storage. For block-based table (usually the case) this includes the block trailer. WART: block `size` may or may not include the trailer; need to be clear about whether it does or not. * **Maybe compressed block** - like a serialized block, but without the trailer (or no promise of including a trailer). Must be accompanied by a CompressionType. * **Uncompressed block** - "payload" bytes that are either stored with no compression, used as input to compression function, or result of decompression function. * **Parsed block** - an in-memory form of a block in block cache, as it is used by the table reader. Different C++ types are used depending on the block type (see block_like_traits.h). Other refactorings: * Misc corrections/improvements of internal API comments * Remove a few misleading / unhelpful / redundant comments. * Use move semantics in some places to simplify contracts * Use better parameter names to indicate which parameters are used for outputs * Remove some extraneous `extern` * Various clean-ups to `CacheDumperImpl` (mostly unnecessary code) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/10408 Test Plan: existing tests Reviewed By: akankshamahajan15 Differential Revision: D38172617 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: ccb99299f324ac5ca46996d34c5089621a4f260c
2022-09-22 18:25:32 +00:00
static_cast<void*>(out_contents));
return ret;
}
Refactor to avoid confusing "raw block" (#10408) Summary: We have a lot of confusing code because of mixed, sometimes completely opposite uses of of the term "raw block" or "raw contents", sometimes within the same source file. For example, in `BlockBasedTableBuilder`, `raw_block_contents` and `raw_size` generally referred to uncompressed block contents and size, while `WriteRawBlock` referred to writing a block that is already compressed if it is going to be. Meanwhile, in `BlockBasedTable`, `raw_block_contents` either referred to a (maybe compressed) block with trailer, or a maybe compressed block maybe without trailer. (Note: left as follow-up work to use C++ typing to better sort out the various kinds of BlockContents.) This change primarily tries to apply some consistent terminology around the kinds of block representations, avoiding the unclear "raw". (Any meaning of "raw" assumes some bias toward the storage layer or toward the logical data layer.) Preferred terminology: * **Serialized block** - bytes that go into storage. For block-based table (usually the case) this includes the block trailer. WART: block `size` may or may not include the trailer; need to be clear about whether it does or not. * **Maybe compressed block** - like a serialized block, but without the trailer (or no promise of including a trailer). Must be accompanied by a CompressionType. * **Uncompressed block** - "payload" bytes that are either stored with no compression, used as input to compression function, or result of decompression function. * **Parsed block** - an in-memory form of a block in block cache, as it is used by the table reader. Different C++ types are used depending on the block type (see block_like_traits.h). Other refactorings: * Misc corrections/improvements of internal API comments * Remove a few misleading / unhelpful / redundant comments. * Use move semantics in some places to simplify contracts * Use better parameter names to indicate which parameters are used for outputs * Remove some extraneous `extern` * Various clean-ups to `CacheDumperImpl` (mostly unnecessary code) Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/10408 Test Plan: existing tests Reviewed By: akankshamahajan15 Differential Revision: D38172617 Pulled By: pdillinger fbshipit-source-id: ccb99299f324ac5ca46996d34c5089621a4f260c
2022-09-22 18:25:32 +00:00
Status UncompressSerializedBlock(const UncompressionInfo& uncompression_info,
const char* data, size_t size,
BlockContents* out_contents,
uint32_t format_version,
const ImmutableOptions& ioptions,
MemoryAllocator* allocator) {
assert(data[size] != kNoCompression);
assert(data[size] == static_cast<char>(uncompression_info.type()));
return UncompressBlockData(uncompression_info, data, size, out_contents,
format_version, ioptions, allocator);
}
// Replace the contents of db_host_id with the actual hostname, if db_host_id
// matches the keyword kHostnameForDbHostId
Status ReifyDbHostIdProperty(Env* env, std::string* db_host_id) {
assert(db_host_id);
if (*db_host_id == kHostnameForDbHostId) {
Status s = env->GetHostNameString(db_host_id);
if (!s.ok()) {
db_host_id->clear();
}
return s;
}
return Status::OK();
}
} // namespace ROCKSDB_NAMESPACE